Used to be very helpful, but poor moderation has led to trans and intersex people being flagged for discussing issues directly related to them, which completely nullifies any usefulness and, worse, actively harms the community.

addon is frequently abused to falsly label trans (especially transmasc) and intersex people as transphobic
this needs to be fixed for an addon like this to be trustworthy

used to be really useful for spotting innocuously-named terfs and transphobe groups, but now it seems like random trans and intersex people are marked as red cause of stupid intracommunity discourse and that really waters it down to the point of uselessness. i dont care if some trans person is posting about being a dude or being intersex in a way that some other trans people dont like, i care if someone is posting shit about the divine feminine womb energy and how trans people are coming for your children. those do not belong in the same category.

Has been increasingly plagued with falsely red users/accounts on multiple sites, often simply for speaking about intersex or transmasc issues. This has always been a small issue with the extension, but it's become widespread recently, and makes it completely unreliable for its purpose as written.

so far it's been really useful

untrustable moderation, the dev explicitly allows for ace-phobic content, while not mentioning a stance on other forms of non-trans LGBT-phobia. People using this extension are targeting transmascs and intersex users and the devs which do "human review" are enabling and engaging in it.

I'm seeing more and more people who are vitriolic towards trans men marked green while people who are actively trans-supportive and even a local trans activist in my community are marked red

no longer useful for what i had been using it for, as someone who is intersex + trans i'm disappointed in the criteria changes and apparent hostility towards intersex trans people.

I've used this app for a long time, and it used to be such a valuable starting point - a 'heads up' to look at accounts carefully - and it felt so good when an account of mine went green! But more and more, I'm finding that red accounts aren't actually anti-trans. Sad to lose what was a useful tool, but if the moderation isn't accurate, then I have to uninstall.

Fantastic tool for finding and labeling transmisogynists, including the many you can find in these reviews :)

Was incredibly useful for blocking TERFs, but now it is marking random transmasculine and intersex individuals who are just sharing normal shit? As an agender person myself, its super disappointing to see this add-on go downhill and try to divide the community.

I used it as a jumping off point for identifying transphobes. very useful as a "you should verify this" flag. however, more trans people/trans allies have been flagged as potentially dangerous recently, making it much less user-friendly.

Very useful for identifying transphobic users, including transmisogynists.

I think the fact that the five star reviews that are being recently uploaded to combat the complaints being levied at Shinigami Eyes contain anti-transmasc language is almost proof in and of itself that these people are biased. If there are all these one-star reviews saying that you're being biased and all you can do to reply to accusations with more bias, you're probably a bit biased!

used to be a very useful addon, now is just a biased bigotted mess

i remember when using slurs was considered to be transphobic. the current problems are By Design, and have been for a while.

this is a disgustingly sexist terf extension downright lying about being community-friendly. i wouldnt be surprised if it came out in a few years it was a psyop to sow division within the community. this is the material effect it has -- i cant wrap my head around the intent.

the double standard and pattern of the terms on the rules page is, bad, to say the least.

1 star reviews now outnumber 5 star ones.

ill avoid making comments towards the creator, because anything i may say would get this review flagged -- i find the extension itself deserving of a red flag using its original, more fair ethos. the current rules page makes my blood boil.
as note (important): trying to find any further info on the current maintainer, etc, anything/anyone to contact further leads to a lot of bad/weird/harmful misinfo! this is separate and only towards the practice of the extension. there is no minority where it is suddenly appropriate to use hate speech.
i was the first person to open an issue on the gh about this -- so i guess ill stack on to the 1 star reviews, if this helps anyone. i really hope this problem can be fixed because of the large size of the userbase (this extension is even in papers!), so it's sad to see this change.

and -- as an important note -- based off some of the dev responses to reviews -- afab transfem is for intersex people. agab terminology is for intersex people, and appropriating it to exclude intersex experiences is, needless to say, Bad. and its also not trans friendly, because it explicitly, and i cannot stress this enough, excludes a specific Kind of trans person (in a way that is bioessentialist! there's nothing noted about amab transmascs is there? and if there was -- i'd be complaining about that too!).
to specifically flag and exclude afab transfems from the community would be to say that the only trans people who matter are perisex. to only highlight specific hate terms against non-binary and perisex transmasculine people as being ok to use would be to imply that the only community experiences that matter are those of transfems -- and that the only people trans enough to deserve protecting -- are transfem.
anything less than "all trans people" (by demographic) is transphobic. i dont know why we cant spotlight the struggles and oppression against one group without specifically putting down and excluding another group. it speaks poorly of transmisogyny as a concept to use it as a bludgeoning tool to silence more vulnerable members of the community, even those who are transfem. im tired.

usually super useful but ive been seeing a weird amount of people flagged as red that have nothing transphobic on their accounts (a lot of them trans themselves and not the reactionary conservative types either) recently. i don't know if they turned over verification to AI but maybe the system needs to be revised because it's really affecting how much i can trust the extension.

used to be a decent tool, now the moderation team seem to have lost it and are marking innocent people -- especially intersex folk, transmen, trans poc and others -- as transphobic. the moderators are discriminatory and are tearing the community apart; don't trust this extension anymore

I used to trust this addon but the recent changes have rendered its point moot. Back to individual manual filtering we go.

Used to love this but then they started marking innocent people for sharing their intersex experiences