Critiques pour Knockoff - Amazon Brand Filter
Knockoff - Amazon Brand Filter par Ordinary Systems
34 notes
- Noté 1 sur 5par neogamerdrew, il y a une heureWent closed source after it became popular and started requesting more permissions. Developer of course has excuses for all this but isn't reverting the changes based on user feedback. Great app ruined by a classic bait and switch :(
Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 4 minutesI was going to write you a lengthy, detailed response to try to help give some perspective on my decisions as a solo developer and help you understand how open source works and reiterate that the original extension is still very much open source and able to be used now and forever, but you wrote your comment in bad faith with a chip on your shoulder mad at the world.
So, instead, here's a hug: 🤗 - Noté 5 sur 5par johnnyp, il y a 7 heuresone of the of the most useful tools ive seen created for the average consumer. amazing work.
- Noté 5 sur 5par WA, il y a un jourThis is an extremely helpful extension, I can't believe how much better this makes Amazon shopping.
- Noté 4 sur 5par Salix223, il y a 2 jours
- Noté 1 sur 5par Equinox0, il y a 2 joursWent closed source, suddenly the addon is requesting more permissions with every update and now wants browsing data. Not to be trusted.
Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a un jourI know lots of extensions have made terrible decisions and taken advantage of folks, but that's not this. You can read all about what permissions are needed here and why.
https://knockoff.co/faq
https://knockoff.co/privacy
If you have specific questions about anything, please email me: josh@knockoff.co
Apps change. They add functionality (user-requested, by the way). And for better or worse, Firefox has *very* generalized categories for these types of permissions that generally make them sound much more heavy-handed than they really are.
But again, lots of folks feel burned by extensions, so I get the sentiment. No rug pull here, just a product that's growing. 🤗 - Noté 1 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 12154263 de Firefox, il y a 2 joursenforces a "shop for US alternatives" button even though i turned it off in setttings as it's not relevant for me. uninstalled.
Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 2 joursIt's a bug! Found the problem and pushing out the fix for it hopefully in the next hour or so. - Noté 2 sur 5par ThingsThatAreWhoo, il y a 2 joursNeat idea and decent execution.
Unfortunately, the developer decided to add new features (one of them mostly useless to people who are not based in the US) that require data collection, marked as browsing activity and website content. These features are on by default, and while they might be harmless in themselves, this kinda kills the canary. The extension does not appear to be open source, yet has a strong media presence and pretty website. Perfect breeding ground for some party to buy it and turn it into something sinister, piggybacking on a huge install base.
I am not saying that's the developer's intention, but it leaves a bad aftertaste in my mouth.
Edit: Correction, older versions are indeed open source. Thanks for reply. The fact however that they are not anymore is an oddity at best.Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 2 joursSorry the extension is no longer a fit for you. More info on why "browsing activity" and "website content" are necessary is covered here: https://knockoff.co/privacy
Any decision I make will be a positive for some a negative for others. Such is the nature of creating things. The code for the earlier versions *is* very much open source and you're more than welcome to download, use, fork, etc: https://github.com/Shpigford/knockoff - Noté 2 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 16970550 de Firefox, il y a 3 jours
- Noté 1 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 20038783 de Firefox, il y a 3 joursExplain why you need this? Has been working fine without. "Required data collection, according to the developer:
Browsing activity
Website content"Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 3 joursFair. 0.8.0 suggests US-based alternatives to a product, so it sends the products you open (ASIN, title, brand, seller). A second feature sends seller IDs to show where a seller is based.
Both are on by default, both switch off in options, and filtering works without either. Stored is a per-product view counter: no IP, no account, no searches.
Unfortunately, Firefox only offers fixed permission labels, and none are narrower than that. - Noté 4 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 20036283 de Firefox, il y a 4 joursBe very careful. This extension seemed like a great idea and I started happily using it in large part
the developer stated that "Everything runs locally in your browser. No accounts, no analytics, no tracking. The only network request is a daily brand-list refresh." However, in the last update the extension now requires a new permission to "collect website content." No information about the purpose of the data collection or the specific data being collected is provided.
Mozilla does provides a link to “Learn More” about the new permission being granted. Their definition of the term ‘website content’ takes a bit of work to find but it seems to be “covers anything visible on a website — such as text, images, videos, and links — and anything embedded, such as cookies, audio, page headers, and request and response information.”
This may or may not be okay. I’m not sure but I am certainly not taking the update until the developer provides more clarity on the purpose of this new permission and what data the extension can and can not collect (e.g., my user name and password, email address, etc.). In any case, the fact that an update was issued with this new permission required with no explanation is very problematic
Update: the developer's response seems quite reasonable so I changed the star rating from one star to four stars. But I'd still prefer an extension that did not collect any website content or browsing activity information because with the way it is now, there still appears to be the possibility of abuse.Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 3 joursSorry about the lack of clarity! Firefox doesn't really provide a great way to surface "why" around a change in permissions (at least not one that doesn't require you to go digging through buried extension changelogs). At any rate.
You're right. That quote is mine, from the 0.1.0 notes. It was true then, but it isn't now, and shipping the change without telling you is my mistake.
0.7.0 and 0.8.0 added two features, both on by default, both switchable off in options:
1. "Seller country" sends seller IDs to show where a seller is based.
2. "Help pick US alternatives" sends the ASIN, title, brand, and seller ID of product pages you open.
To your question: no, it cannot see your username, password, or email. It reads a few specific product elements and sends only those fields. Never form inputs, cookies, searches, or orders. Server-side it's one row per product with a view counter. No IP, session, or account stored beside it.
The labels are Firefox's fixed vocabulary. There's no bucket for "just the product page you're on," so I declared the honest maximum rather than under-declare. Mozilla's definition describes the category ceiling, not what Knockoff does.
Working on updating our Firefox listing now to clarify this.
Thanks for the feedback! - Noté 1 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 20035832 de Firefox, il y a 4 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par Andrew G Lucas, il y a 5 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par Mr Leaf, il y a 5 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par davidohara, il y a 6 joursMandatory for using Amazon.
God bless the developers.
I cannot use Amazon without using this. - Noté 5 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 14665809 de Firefox, il y a 7 joursWorks as described. I was looking for an OEM item in Amazon the other day. The results even with a brand name were so full of knockoffs that I thought they didn't carry what I was looking for. Surprise, they do sell it and only because I used the plugin was I able to find what I was looking for. Thanks!
- Noté 5 sur 5par RN, il y a 7 joursYou are doing God's work. Absolute kudos, I'm gonna go look and see if I can sponsor you on GitHub.
- Noté 5 sur 5par qwertzu, il y a 7 joursworks well, I wish it would expand to other platforms than Amazon
- Noté 5 sur 5par riot, il y a 8 joursMan. We used to get addons/extensions like this back in the day all of the damn time. What a simple idea executed to perfection. Love the ability to hide or dim. Now if Amazon brought back the ability to comment on peoples reviews that'd be great.
- Noté 5 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 19659081 de Firefox, il y a 8 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par d1nd141, il y a 8 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par EarthCitizen, il y a 9 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 15037205 de Firefox, il y a 9 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par B.C., il y a 9 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 17828049 de Firefox, il y a 9 joursI love this already and I'm excited to see where it goes. Especially valuable to me is the ability to hide all the sponsored listings. This is something I was doing mentally and it was exhausting to try to skip past all the untrustworthy pay-to-play stuff.
- Noté 3 sur 5par Afzal, il y a 9 joursGreat idea but rudimentary filtering method that catches a lot of false positives.
Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 9 joursTo be clear, it has a heavy "community note" feature that improves the filtering constantly for everyone. If you see a false positive, just report it and it'll be manually reviewed.