Critiques pour Firefox Multi-Account Containers
Firefox Multi-Account Containers par Firefox
Avis de GoodOldMonkey
Noté 2 sur 5
par GoodOldMonkey, il y a 8 ansSadly, demoted from ☆☆☆ to ☆as of 7 July 2021. Starting ten days ago, the extension was unable to associate different logins to a domain with my different accounts: Google Drive was always personal, or always work. Since Independence Day, it's been trying to fix that by jumping frantically back and forth between different containers in the same tab - window jitters like crazy, and your only option is to close the tab. Today the jitter spreads to previously stable tabs when you close a schizophrenic one. The only solution: turn the extension off, and lose all the walls between different roles.
This is a great idea, and I hope the Mozilla team figures out how to make it WORK RELIABLY. Meanwhile, I'm going to be making a lot more use of Chrome personas.
When I gave this add-on a five-star rating, (see below) I didn't realize:
IF YOU TURN IT OFF, ALL YOUR SETTINGS GET WIPED OUT.
I had a couple of hundred URLs associated with my personal, work, coding, educational and Facebook IDs. To see if add-ons were making Firefox a memory hog, I turned them all off. When I reactivated Multi-Account Containers, the only associations that remained were with "Personal" and those were all wrongly linked to my coding persona.
So now I'm wondering if I want to take the trouble of rebuilding — at least a half day of work to undo what should never have happened. If Mozilla security protocol means an inactive add-on can't retain any data, there should have been a CONSPICUOUS WARNING of what I was erasing.
=========earlier review=========
If you are an admin — Google apps account, a Facebook page, whatever — you can finally sign is as a user/visitor at the same time you're editing, in side-by-side tabs in the same browser. And it's nice to have access to a persona not associated with any of your social media or email accounts, so you can escape tracking and junk email when you browse.
This is a great idea, and I hope the Mozilla team figures out how to make it WORK RELIABLY. Meanwhile, I'm going to be making a lot more use of Chrome personas.
When I gave this add-on a five-star rating, (see below) I didn't realize:
IF YOU TURN IT OFF, ALL YOUR SETTINGS GET WIPED OUT.
I had a couple of hundred URLs associated with my personal, work, coding, educational and Facebook IDs. To see if add-ons were making Firefox a memory hog, I turned them all off. When I reactivated Multi-Account Containers, the only associations that remained were with "Personal" and those were all wrongly linked to my coding persona.
So now I'm wondering if I want to take the trouble of rebuilding — at least a half day of work to undo what should never have happened. If Mozilla security protocol means an inactive add-on can't retain any data, there should have been a CONSPICUOUS WARNING of what I was erasing.
=========earlier review=========
If you are an admin — Google apps account, a Facebook page, whatever — you can finally sign is as a user/visitor at the same time you're editing, in side-by-side tabs in the same browser. And it's nice to have access to a persona not associated with any of your social media or email accounts, so you can escape tracking and junk email when you browse.
7 877 notes
- Noté 5 sur 5par DDB, il y a 5 heures
- Noté 5 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 14515734 de Firefox, il y a 14 heures
- Noté 5 sur 5par KurChr, il y a un jourNeeded to have multiple Web Outlook email accounts open simultaneously. Worked great. If pinned the accounts came back up without logging in again if Firefox exited and restarted. Would be absolutely perfect for me if the accounts came back up after a Restart.
- Noté 3 sur 5par Randomfox, il y a 2 joursDoesn't work well containing Google, can't sign in on gemini.google.com
- Noté 5 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 19625591 de Firefox, il y a 2 jours
- Noté 1 sur 5par 0x666c697473, il y a 4 joursGuaranteed to silently drop containers in the middle of your workflow, with no github interest in even acknowledging the problem.
- Noté 1 sur 5par spindog, il y a 5 jourssyncing is pointless. i'm done setting up site lists every time it resets when logging in on new devices.
- Noté 1 sur 5par Davide, il y a 6 joursThe Firefox Sync integration is horrible - it keeps merging back old changes. Container settings get reverted, and old removed containers come back...
- Noté 3 sur 5par Sean Critz, il y a 6 joursThis extension needs some work before it fits the concept. In situations where multiple accounts need to be managed on the same website (using multiple microsoft accounts for different clients, for instance) , it is generally not usable. The following workflow breaks it:
- Open tab in X container, login to a service
- Service uses redirects to authenticate, container extension grabs those redirects and loses the container status or changes the container status, breaking the login flow or putting a different login into the context
Additionally, there does not seem to be an option to remove a site from a container preference, once added. - Noté 5 sur 5par René, il y a 6 joursDe ideale manier om met meerdere accounts en een domein te werken zonder van profiel te hoeven wisselen.
- Noté 5 sur 5par Steve S, il y a 8 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 14376762 de Firefox, il y a 10 joursWorks well for seperating my tracked internet history, without needing to setup a second Firefox Profile & Mozilla Account. This in addition to the Facebook, Google & Twitter Containers help keep those 3 from tying everywhere I go on the 'net to my accounts.
- Noté 4 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 13252902 de Firefox, il y a 13 joursReally helps at keeping some of the problematic sites contained. Could use some polishing but very useful addition.
- Noté 5 sur 5par fazlan, il y a 13 joursthis is the god extension for me. my life saver please continue. dont stop ever. i love you firefox
- Noté 3 sur 5par Mackintosh´s, il y a 14 joursPlease change environment bonds to Deep Links instead of only Top Level Domains. Ask whether the container should always open up when the current deep link is opened or whenever any site of the top level domain is opened.
- Noté 5 sur 5par Dan, il y a 16 jours
- Noté 4 sur 5par ChosenFate, il y a 17 joursThis is great in concept, however, the friction kills it for me. After adding a site to a container, whenever I now open a link of that site, I get asked whether I wanna open it in that container. Of course I do, I mean, I manually added it to that container. This only needs to be done once per site, but it's still unnecessary friction that just about tips it over to "more pain than gain" unfortunately. Please make an option to always open a given site in it's container no matter what
- Noté 5 sur 5par Chinmay Rajyaguru, il y a 18 joursThis is very powerful tool for productivity. I shifted from Chrome to Firefox a week ago.
- Noté 4 sur 5par thomasa88, il y a 22 joursThis add-on works very well and I use it every day!
However, there are some things that I think could be improved:
First, when opening a webpage that has a container assigned, I get the choice between "open in current" tab and "open in x container". I would like to be able to select from all my containers directly on that page.
Second, when reopening Firefox, all tabs that get reloaded when clicking on them triggers the "choose container" page.
Also, choosing the option to not open a new tab for container pages led to some weird tab interactions, but I can't remember exactly what happened. - Noté 5 sur 5par Rawe, il y a 23 jours
- Noté 1 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 12912919 de Firefox, il y a un moisNão é gratuito. Tem que pagar e instalar o VPN para windows. Ridiculo, só avisam que é pago depois que instalar o ADDON.
- Noté 5 sur 5par Naveen Kumar, il y a un mois
- Noté 4 sur 5par IntensiveExtensions, il y a un moisPlease make this feature available on Android. This extension is useful!