Beoardielingen foar Cookie Manager
Cookie Manager troch Rob W
Wurdearringen foar joebt
Wurdearring: 3 fan 5
troch joebt, 8 jierren lynThanks for beginning a cookie manager for Fx 57+. I know it's brand new & takes a lot of work. Just trying to give some useful suggestions.
1) Re: Taurean75's comment: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/a-cookie-manager/reviews/896808/ - -
yes, I think they meant as in the link you posted: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/Add-ons/WebExtensions/user_interface/Popups.
That's the way many addons provide menus, where options may require frequent changing.
2) If I understand, why have any addon open in a NEW TAB, instead of using a toolbar icon? Not a requirement for Fx 57 / webextensions? Or just the fastest way to get Cookie Manager up & running?
Most Fx 57 ready addons I use allow adding icons with drop menus to toolbar. Few require using about:addons to *change* (most) options - especially for cookies.
3) Suggestion: post a few more screenshots on MAO w/ some explanations. Probably entice more users to try it. I see Cookie Monster's dev has pulled it from AMO. Lots of users will be looking for replacement.
Keep up the good work. For ideas, I'd look at features in the more popular cookie managers - that aren't updating to webextensions.
If you want feedback of what's most important to users to implement 1st, maybe setup a support page on http://forums.mozillazine.org, as other addon devs did. One post could be a poll for wish list.
I could tell you some cookie features I've used most - for years, & read others say were important to them, but it'd make this review long(er). Maybe you don't need ideas for now. :) But, feel free to PM me.
Edited review 08/13/2017: correct typos
1) Re: Taurean75's comment: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/a-cookie-manager/reviews/896808/ - -
yes, I think they meant as in the link you posted: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/Add-ons/WebExtensions/user_interface/Popups.
That's the way many addons provide menus, where options may require frequent changing.
2) If I understand, why have any addon open in a NEW TAB, instead of using a toolbar icon? Not a requirement for Fx 57 / webextensions? Or just the fastest way to get Cookie Manager up & running?
Most Fx 57 ready addons I use allow adding icons with drop menus to toolbar. Few require using about:addons to *change* (most) options - especially for cookies.
3) Suggestion: post a few more screenshots on MAO w/ some explanations. Probably entice more users to try it. I see Cookie Monster's dev has pulled it from AMO. Lots of users will be looking for replacement.
Keep up the good work. For ideas, I'd look at features in the more popular cookie managers - that aren't updating to webextensions.
If you want feedback of what's most important to users to implement 1st, maybe setup a support page on http://forums.mozillazine.org, as other addon devs did. One post could be a poll for wish list.
I could tell you some cookie features I've used most - for years, & read others say were important to them, but it'd make this review long(er). Maybe you don't need ideas for now. :) But, feel free to PM me.
Edited review 08/13/2017: correct typos
Antwurd ûntwikkeler
8 jierren lyn pleatst> Curious-why open an addon in a new tab?
When I wrote this extension many years ago, I wanted to only enable it when I wanted to edit cookies, which is rarely.
When I published the add-on to Firefox, the initial use case is Firefox for Android, which does not have an extension button (as of Firefox 55, it is possible).
In version 1.3, I have added an option to not automatically open the add-on upon startup, and also an extension button to quickly access the cookie manager via the extension button.
3) The add-on is functional, but the UI is not really that strong. I expect the UI to be improved in one of the next versions, so I haven't published a screenshot yet.
> If you want feedback (...) maybe setup a support page
I have published the source code on Github, together with an issue tracker @ https://github.com/Rob--W/cookie-manager/issues
When I wrote this extension many years ago, I wanted to only enable it when I wanted to edit cookies, which is rarely.
When I published the add-on to Firefox, the initial use case is Firefox for Android, which does not have an extension button (as of Firefox 55, it is possible).
In version 1.3, I have added an option to not automatically open the add-on upon startup, and also an extension button to quickly access the cookie manager via the extension button.
3) The add-on is functional, but the UI is not really that strong. I expect the UI to be improved in one of the next versions, so I haven't published a screenshot yet.
> If you want feedback (...) maybe setup a support page
I have published the source code on Github, together with an issue tracker @ https://github.com/Rob--W/cookie-manager/issues
124 beoardielingen
- Wurdearring: 2 fan 5troch Davide, 2 moannen lynStrange, it doesn't work anymore. It makes my Firefox freeze completely (99% CPU)
- Wurdearring: 1 fan 5troch Jm, 7 moannen lynThis ap does not remove all cookies or other cookie-like traces left by most sites. If you go to Tools>Settings>Privacy& Security> Manage Data and click twice on "Last used" you will see most recent cookies left by all sites. You will also see the ones Cookie Manager leaves on your computer. You can delete them from there so why use Cook. Mgr. and then have to visit Tools to complete the removal??
- Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch BoilingOil, 8 moannen lynNot happy about the removal of the very helpful option to quickly set the search time/date to NOW. That was actually the most useful feature this extension had, and now it's gone... -2 stars for that.
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Dan, 8 moannen lynI successfully removed cookies for a specific site on Firefox for Android.
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch gmonly, ien jier lynseems to work good, the cookie quick manager would not work for me. this one not only lets you delete some, it also lets you edit them
- Wurdearring: 4 fan 5troch jean f..., ien jier lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 15974441, ien jier lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Aidan Stewart, ien jier lyn
- Wurdearring: 1 fan 5troch MartyGreg, 2 jierren lynFor a normal user who wants to see all cookies and be able to delete some or all, this is unusable.
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 18054980, 2 jierren lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Yahoshu Masih, 2 jierren lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 13768161, 3 jierren lynLet me find a cookie that neither Firefox nor the most popular cookie extension would. Thanks!
- Wurdearring: 1 fan 5troch Laconia, 3 jierren lyn
- Wurdearring: 1 fan 5troch strigoi, 3 jierren lynThis add-on doesn't work with the latest FF v, which version can I use to have this extension working please?
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch criticabug, 3 jierren lynYes, works fine with Firefox for Android (Fenix).
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch FreeLibre, 3 jierren lyn
- Wurdearring: 4 fan 5troch Illuminator, 3 jierren lyn
- Wurdearring: 4 fan 5troch John Doe, 3 jierren lynThis addon is great for Firefox. But there are no Chrome cookie addon that supports importing from this addon's exported cookies. They (cookie addons available on Chrome web store) doesn't recognize JSON cookie file that exported by Cookie Manager. I'd love to see Chrome version of Cookie Manager!
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Rioniil, 3 jierren lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Onurtag, 4 jierren lynI tried all cookie manager addons and picked this one.
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Александр, 4 jierren lyn
- Wurdearring: 5 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 16975662, 4 jierren lyn