Unpaywall のレビュー
Unpaywall 作成者: Impactstory team
Firefox ユーザー 13958296 によるレビュー
5 段階中 2 の評価
Firefox ユーザー 13958296 によるレビュー (8年前)TL;DR:
Implement the best possible interface, regardless of lazy users' concerns, then create an easy version for them. Or at least make a second version that follows best-practices. Somewhat redundant program, otherwise. But great idea, and there's certainly something to be said for the fact that you've pursued the idea to this extent.
Full comment:
Echoing the sentiments of another reviewer, and the respective reply from dev...
"Best-practices" in mind, it's too bad that they're being sullied in favour of unskilled-user-friendliness. Kind of ends up being user-unfriendly for those who would use in a more 'serious'/efficient capacity...
My opinion, for what it's worth, is that best-practices ought to be pursued foremost, otherwise the tool becomes an interface nightmare for those who want to use it efficiently and thoughtfully. You'd end up with a better product and that's the best scenario for a creator. A lite version is perfectly reasonable once that's taken care of.
I appreciate what you've done, though, and understand where you're coming from. It's a fantastic idea, but problematic roll-out philosophy for me. Ends up being a bit of another time-consuming hoop to jump through which sort of defeats the purpose for those who are capable, yet looking to streamline the search and organization process.
Implement the best possible interface, regardless of lazy users' concerns, then create an easy version for them. Or at least make a second version that follows best-practices. Somewhat redundant program, otherwise. But great idea, and there's certainly something to be said for the fact that you've pursued the idea to this extent.
Full comment:
Echoing the sentiments of another reviewer, and the respective reply from dev...
"Best-practices" in mind, it's too bad that they're being sullied in favour of unskilled-user-friendliness. Kind of ends up being user-unfriendly for those who would use in a more 'serious'/efficient capacity...
My opinion, for what it's worth, is that best-practices ought to be pursued foremost, otherwise the tool becomes an interface nightmare for those who want to use it efficiently and thoughtfully. You'd end up with a better product and that's the best scenario for a creator. A lite version is perfectly reasonable once that's taken care of.
I appreciate what you've done, though, and understand where you're coming from. It's a fantastic idea, but problematic roll-out philosophy for me. Ends up being a bit of another time-consuming hoop to jump through which sort of defeats the purpose for those who are capable, yet looking to streamline the search and organization process.
合計レビュー数: 248
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 19625280 によるレビュー (3ヶ月前)Has worked great for me. Sometimes it requires clicking the unlock twice on two different sites. There are also instances where it comes up grey, but the article is available on libgen FYI
- 5 段階中 5 の評価BIRBMASTERZER0 によるレビュー (3ヶ月前)
- 5 段階中 1 の評価Firefox ユーザー 13404543 によるレビュー (4ヶ月前)
- 5 段階中 3 の評価Astro_Dude83 によるレビュー (4ヶ月前)I'll give this an extra star because it does apparently work for many others, but not for me. I've ran into research papers in Nature, Astronomy and Astrophysics, The Astrophysical Journal, and many others that were behind a paywall, where the green unlocked icon came up, indicating it had located an open access version. However, hitting it just opens the webpage I'm on again in a new tab with another green icon that does the same. If this worked as intended for me, it would save countless hours of searching repositories like arxiv myself. Bummer.
As it stands, the one very useful function it serves, is if the icon comes up grey and locked, I know not to waste my time searching for an open access version elsewhere, or asking AI to scour the web for something that doesn't exist (AI deep research always confirms this).
Note: After reading through these comments, there seems to be a great deal of confusion about what Unpaywall does. First off, this is NOT for news and online magazine articles. For that you want the RemovePaywalls.com extension. Unpaywall is for scholarly articles, such as academic research papers. Also, Unpaywall doesn't "Break through" the paywall and open the research paper up on the publisher's site. It searches the web for a site where you can read it legally without paying, so you don't have to do it yourself. If the icon comes up grey and locked, it doesn't mean it's not working. It means it couldn't find an open copy in any of the usual places. Last, if it's not working for you, try disabling ad blockers and other extensions, since they can interfere with all sorts of things. - 5 段階中 5 の評価ilovemikael によるレビュー (8ヶ月前)
- 5 段階中 1 の評価Firefox ユーザー 19023747 によるレビュー (9ヶ月前)
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 18862493 によるレビュー (1年前)Does what it's supposed to do. Awesome add-on, as education should be free!
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 17823156 によるレビュー (1年前)
- 5 段階中 5 の評価PimpinDragon によるレビュー (1年前)
- 5 段階中 4 の評価Firefox ユーザー 14966199 によるレビュー (1年前)
- 5 段階中 5 の評価johnnyfrog によるレビュー (1年前)
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 18602700 によるレビュー (1年前)