NoScript Security Suite에 대한 리뷰
NoScript Security Suite 제작자: Giorgio Maone
Firefox 사용자 14298576 님의 리뷰
5점 만점에 3점
Firefox 사용자 14298576 님, 7년 전First off, I've used NoScript for a number of years and have donated and am hovering between 2-3 stars due to the terrible UI.
Unfortunately the UI remains extremely poor, with confusing wording and very bad icon designs (w.r.t usability, nevermind esthetics). The UI uses double negatives, which is bad (ref: MS and Apple). This may be a side effect of Italian translation.
There is not differentiation with colour: blue and red are used in the icons regardless if something is "safe" or "unsafe". The exclamation mark doesn't work that well for conveying meaning (it's "sort of" a warning, but then the "stop sign" is also used - but now the stop sign means, "stop restricting" (again - double negative))
E.g.
S!: disable restrictions (change icon. to, almost anything, change wording to: "Allow everything (including blocked scripts)")
!: disable restrictions for this tab (change icon to almost anything else, change wording to: "Allow everything on this tab. (Maintain restrictions on blocked domains)")
Clock!: Set all to temporarily trusted (change icon, "Temporarily Trust everything on this tab. (Maintain restrictions on blocked domains)" )
Clock + Stop symbol: revoke temporary permissions (change icon, wording to "Normal operation"?)
Unfortunately the UI remains extremely poor, with confusing wording and very bad icon designs (w.r.t usability, nevermind esthetics). The UI uses double negatives, which is bad (ref: MS and Apple). This may be a side effect of Italian translation.
There is not differentiation with colour: blue and red are used in the icons regardless if something is "safe" or "unsafe". The exclamation mark doesn't work that well for conveying meaning (it's "sort of" a warning, but then the "stop sign" is also used - but now the stop sign means, "stop restricting" (again - double negative))
E.g.
S!: disable restrictions (change icon. to, almost anything, change wording to: "Allow everything (including blocked scripts)")
!: disable restrictions for this tab (change icon to almost anything else, change wording to: "Allow everything on this tab. (Maintain restrictions on blocked domains)")
Clock!: Set all to temporarily trusted (change icon, "Temporarily Trust everything on this tab. (Maintain restrictions on blocked domains)" )
Clock + Stop symbol: revoke temporary permissions (change icon, wording to "Normal operation"?)
리뷰 2,369개
- 5점 만점에 5점Firefox 사용자 19047433 님, 2일 전
- 5점 만점에 5점A. Bilmanda 님, 5일 전
- 5점 만점에 5점Lazer Bear 님, 5일 전
- 5점 만점에 2점Firefox 사용자 15056996 님, 23일 전issues with outdoorline.sk ; I have to stop Noscrypt to proceed with Payment gateway GP webpay
- 5점 만점에 4점Firefox 사용자 17847461 님, 한 달 전
- 5점 만점에 5점Firefox 사용자 18989716 님, 한 달 전
- I really wanted to use NoScript. I prefer single-purpose extensions that focus on doing one job well, compared to more multi-purpose extensions like uBlock Origin.
However, I ultimately couldn't stick with it because the user experience did not suit my needs.
E.g. one mobile screen presents around 12 different icons packed into the height of 3 lines of text, leaving a large portion of the screen completely empty below them.
My main frustration is that none of these icons have labels. Expecting users to learn and memorize the meaning of a dozen different unlabeled symbols creates an unnecessary barrier to entry and makes using the extension quickly and efficiently very difficult. It feels counter-intuitive to leave so much screen real estate blank when that space could be used to label each icon and explain its function.
uBlock Origin is easier to use than NoScript. - 5점 만점에 5점LittleFire 님, 한 달 전
- 5점 만점에 4점Firefox 사용자 18920843 님, 한 달 전
- 5점 만점에 5점Firefox 사용자 18315395 님, 2달 전
- 5점 만점에 5점Retromania 님, 2달 전
- 5점 만점에 5점Luciano Rangel 님, 2달 전
- 5점 만점에 5점Firefox 사용자 18924473 님, 2달 전