YCS - YouTube Comment Search (Continued)에 대한 리뷰
YCS - YouTube Comment Search (Continued) 제작자: Pymaster
Firefox 사용자 13302641 님의 리뷰
5점 만점에 5점
Firefox 사용자 13302641 님, 일 년 전리뷰 32개
- 5점 만점에 2점Headhunter 님, 일 년 전Finally! One of the best expansion in my FF
But it stopped working.
THX for super fast fixing!
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ - 5점 만점에 5점SpringCatalogue 님, 일 년 전thank you so much for forking this. Hadzy (a website) can only do so much.
- Doesn't handle whitespace. Searching for "pro" returns comments that contain standalone instances of "pro" but also any comment containing a string with pro in it, like "pronounce" or "product." That's fine, but then if I search for "pro " with a space after pro, I get the exact same results.
Also, and this is not a big deal, it highlights substrings that are one character shorter than what you type in. So when I searched for "pro" it for some reason highlighted any instances of "pr" in the comment. Note that this doesn't actually affect which comments are returned, it's just a highlighting issue. So if you search for "pro" and a comment said "practice profiling perps," it would show up as a search result, and the pr in practice and the pr in profiling would be highlighted. But if a comment said "practice running," it would not show up as a result, so that's good.
Edit: thank you for the response! If I click "extended search" then searching using whitespace (in quotes) does indeed yield the correct results. As noted in that github thread, it no longer highlights the identified string in the comments when extended search is checked, but that's no big deal. Also the issue I mentioned with it highlighting a string that's one character shorter than the string searched for is not happening today, so that's cool.개발자 답글
일 년 전에 게시됨The searching/highlighting behaviors you mentioned were introduced in the original YCS extension.
I know it's kind of unintuitive, but the original author might have thought it through.
So I tend to leave it as it is for now.
For further explanation about the behavior, please visit the issue comment below:
https://github.com/pc035860/YCS-cont/issues/7#issuecomment-2158208293 - Thank you for continuing this addon, it didn't work at first, then I discovered it seems to conflict in some way with PocketTube extension, it won't load comments when PT is enabled, but disabling it fixes the issue. Any chance of looking into this? I'd like to use both simultaneously.
개발자 답글
일 년 전에 게시됨Both PocketTube extensions seem to modify an important global data variable referenced by many YouTube-related extensions. Somehow, this only happens in Firefox (I guess the author might not even know).
As a result, YCS extension can't retrieve the required config data to make proper comments fetching requests to YouTube.
I'll see what I can do in YCS to preserve or regenerate the required data.