Análises para Tridactyl
Tridactyl por Colin Caine, Oliver Blanthorn
Análise por bool3max
EDIT: The more and more and I use it the more bugs I find. e.g. :tabopen opens 3 blank tabs every time it is used. Extremely annoying.
Lots of really annoying quirks that are not limitations of this addon but of the WebExtension API. Thus we can't really factor them in the review.
Some of them include not being able to use any bindings before a page has fully loaded, not being able to use bindings on about:blank, etc...
One major factor that could definitely be improved upon is performance. There's a noticeable delay when switching tabs and especially when typing commands in the console.
Also the link-follow UI with the giant yellow rectangles is atrocious. Lots of duplicate links, poor visibility. Vim Vixen does much better in that regard.
Other than that the addon is really good and I appreciate all the work that's been put into it. Once the WebExtension API improves I don't doubt that we'll see a lot of improvements in Tridactyl too.
Lots of really annoying quirks that are not limitations of this addon but of the WebExtension API. Thus we can't really factor them in the review.
Some of them include not being able to use any bindings before a page has fully loaded, not being able to use bindings on about:blank, etc...
One major factor that could definitely be improved upon is performance. There's a noticeable delay when switching tabs and especially when typing commands in the console.
Also the link-follow UI with the giant yellow rectangles is atrocious. Lots of duplicate links, poor visibility. Vim Vixen does much better in that regard.
Other than that the addon is really good and I appreciate all the work that's been put into it. Once the WebExtension API improves I don't doubt that we'll see a lot of improvements in Tridactyl too.
Resposta do programador
publicado a há 6 anosThanks for the review. We're aware and working on most of the issues you've mentioned.
> [... T]he link-follow UI with the giant yellow rectangles is atrocious. Lots of duplicate links, poor visibility. Vim Vixen does much better in that regard.
Please could you file an issue detailing the page(s) where you see duplicate links, or they have poor visibility? We've tried quite hard to remove duplicates from hints. Our issues page is here: https://github.com/tridactyl/tridactyl/issues
Thanks!
> [... T]he link-follow UI with the giant yellow rectangles is atrocious. Lots of duplicate links, poor visibility. Vim Vixen does much better in that regard.
Please could you file an issue detailing the page(s) where you see duplicate links, or they have poor visibility? We've tried quite hard to remove duplicates from hints. Our issues page is here: https://github.com/tridactyl/tridactyl/issues
Thanks!
495 análises
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por Utilizador do Firefox 19201857 , há 2 dias
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por rebelyell , há 24 dias
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por tyleralbee , há um mês
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por yesyouken , há 2 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por elitesustenance , há 2 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por BobTheDeleter , há 2 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por Chris Fleming , há 2 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por Utilizador do Firefox 14956793 , há 2 mesesThe addon is brilliant!
I prefer it to Vimium as 'F' works on tabs where Vimium wouldn't even register them. - Avaliado em 5 de 5por jieran233 , há 2 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por Utilizador do Firefox 19031464 , há 3 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por Kassius , há 3 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por djmbritt , há 3 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por dallyger , há 3 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por Caixinha , há 4 mesesVery well made extension. Easy to customize. Nice dev support. After some time it becomes impossible to use Firefox without.
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por Hosein , há 4 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por fugue , há 4 mesesThis is the best vim-addict enabling addon on the web! I absolutely can't get enough!
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por Utilizador do Firefox 18914417 , há 5 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por Elijah Immer , há 6 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por J. Lee , há 6 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por Utilizador do Firefox 12745314 , há 7 meses
- Avaliado em 5 de 5por Utilizador do Firefox 18422486 , há 8 mesesI love this and can't live without it. There's some issues I'd love to see taken care of, if even possible.
Sometimes I need to click on a blank space on a page to make tridactyl perform an action, like scrolling with J/K, or typing a command with ":" .
Second issue I have is where I activate hint mode with F, and there are way too many hint labels on a specific element, many of which don't do anything, and only one that actually does something. Maybe it could be implementet that hint labels that don't do anything when typed are hidden from hint mode, and that hints that do the same thing (like click the same button) are merged into each other.
3rd issue is that on using t to tabopen, it searches not just the urls from my bookmarks and history, it also searches in the tab "titles", which is for example "Tridactyl – Get this Extension for 🦊 Firefox (en-US)" for this mozilla page. I'd like to just search in urls from my bookmarks and history, not those titles too.
Also when using t to tabopen, I'd like it to open the page at the top when pressing enter, instead of searching what I just typed in. Because now I have to press the Tab key everytime I want to open the top url. I don't want to search the part after :tabopen, because I would have just used the s/S key to search.
Tridactyl breaks microsoft teams by the way, so I had to do :blacklistadd teams.microsoft.com.
I also look forward to tridactyl working on addons.mozilla.org and other sites.