Отзывы на «Shinigami Eyes»
Shinigami Eyes от Shinigami Eyes
Отзывы Waap
You cannot rely on this extension (or anything like it, for that matter) to replace personal research and critical thinking.
The political biases of the creators with regards to who is part of the trans community, what is or is not transphobic, what language is or is not appropriate, etc. directly impact the TOS and intended purpose of this extension, so if your politics diverge at all (which they likely will, just because of how many stances there are to have), labels on accounts and pages may mislead you.
On top of this, users can and do falsely flag accounts as trans-friendly or transphobic (I've personally been marked friendly before for simply being part of a trans-positive group which is not what the label is meant to mean, but this feature can also easily be used maliciously), and high numbers of people using the extension results in false or misleading flags having a huge impact on the amount of engagement a user gets, which homogenises what LGBT+ talking points and perspectives get seen online.
Extensions such as this can be handy at times, but without attached explanation for why a user is marked the way they are, it acts less like an informative tool and more like a prosthetic gut instinct with someone else's biases baked into it instead of your own.
I'm personally removing this extension in response to a blog that should qualify for the trans-friendly label being irreversably marked as transphobic by the creators due to political disagreement, likely on the specifics of the relationship between the intersex and transgender communities. The blog owner does a lot of really important outreach and IRL community work, and has unique and important perspectives that a lot of people will no longer engage with because of the false label.
It was nice to have quick information to look to when something didn't quite sit right with me because I have a lot of trouble trusting my own instincts, but on further meditation I'm not OK with a tool like this deciding how I should feel for me.
If you do choose to install the extension, please consider its labels an invitation to inspect further and figure out why that label is there, instead of simply taking it as an objective marker of who is or is not safe. Nobody can judge what is or is not safe for you except yourself.
The political biases of the creators with regards to who is part of the trans community, what is or is not transphobic, what language is or is not appropriate, etc. directly impact the TOS and intended purpose of this extension, so if your politics diverge at all (which they likely will, just because of how many stances there are to have), labels on accounts and pages may mislead you.
On top of this, users can and do falsely flag accounts as trans-friendly or transphobic (I've personally been marked friendly before for simply being part of a trans-positive group which is not what the label is meant to mean, but this feature can also easily be used maliciously), and high numbers of people using the extension results in false or misleading flags having a huge impact on the amount of engagement a user gets, which homogenises what LGBT+ talking points and perspectives get seen online.
Extensions such as this can be handy at times, but without attached explanation for why a user is marked the way they are, it acts less like an informative tool and more like a prosthetic gut instinct with someone else's biases baked into it instead of your own.
I'm personally removing this extension in response to a blog that should qualify for the trans-friendly label being irreversably marked as transphobic by the creators due to political disagreement, likely on the specifics of the relationship between the intersex and transgender communities. The blog owner does a lot of really important outreach and IRL community work, and has unique and important perspectives that a lot of people will no longer engage with because of the false label.
It was nice to have quick information to look to when something didn't quite sit right with me because I have a lot of trouble trusting my own instincts, but on further meditation I'm not OK with a tool like this deciding how I should feel for me.
If you do choose to install the extension, please consider its labels an invitation to inspect further and figure out why that label is there, instead of simply taking it as an objective marker of who is or is not safe. Nobody can judge what is or is not safe for you except yourself.
1 305 отзывов
- Оценено на 5 из 5от Пользователь Firefox 19672014, 2 дня назад
- Оценено на 1 из 5от kuu, 2 дня назад
- Оценено на 1 из 5от LegatusFlagrans, 2 дня назадI've used this extension for many years as a trans woman always on the lookout for who might not be so friendly towards people like me, and for a while it was pretty good.
That's all changed dramatically within the last year. I began recently to notice just how many pages and people and websites were obviously false-flagged as transphobic by the extension, despite clear and overwhelming support for non-cis identities and no record of transphobia to be found. Even the LGBTQIA+ wiki and Pride Flag wiki were being flagged.
And that's when I learned that its creator is a transmedicalist who hates trans men, intersex people, neopronoun users, and people with nonhuman identities, and has been completely on board with its abuse by people with similar bigotries.
I can only conclude that this extension is now totally unreliable for its stated purpose, and now strongly discourage its use by anyone who's looking to actually curate their spaces.
What an absolute waste of what was once a good thing. - Оценено на 1 из 5от Fox Fortuna, 2 дня назадEnshittified and abused to the point that it is no longer fit for purpose.
- Оценено на 1 из 5от Fr0stBites, 4 дня назадthis USED to be a good addon and genuinely marked only terfs as red. nowadays it marks literally any transmasc, intersex, or nonbinary person as red for existing and being proud. transfems are also marked red if they post anything about supporting ALL trans people. this addon is FOR terfs at this point 👎
- Оценено на 1 из 5от RedVelvet, 11 дней назадThis app is decent but sometimes is used as a bludgeon by terfs marking the average trans/enby poc red. I won't say to uninstall it but do not implicitly believe that every marking it's ever made is true and unbiased. Sorry, but you're still going to have to do your homework if you want to know if someone is transphobic or not.
- Оценено на 4 из 5от beanstalks, 14 дней назад
- Оценено на 1 из 5от Otter, 14 дней назадDoes not work as it claims to. I've seen multiple radfem and well known terf accounts marked green, and vocally pro queer and trans friendly accounts marked red.
- Оценено на 1 из 5от Illusn, 15 дней назадIncorrectly marks trans men, nonbinary people and intersex people as anti-trans in a way that can only be malicious
- Оценено на 1 из 5от Venus, 15 дней назадWhite transfems can say the most vile transphobic stuff ever and still be marked green, but any poc that's enby/transmasc/2spirit/intersex and calls them out for it gets marked red. Mhm. Uninstalled.
- Оценено на 5 из 5от disasterBi, 15 дней назадSeeing a few 1 star reviews but I feel like people don't understand that this extension uses people marking accounts as anti-trans/trans friendly to show them as red/green. I can count on one hand the amount of times I've had false positives, all you need to do is check people's posts, not whether they're trans themselves.
- Оценено на 1 из 5от cemetery--drive, 15 дней назадThis extension used to be really useful but I've seen multiple trans people who are outspoken advocates for equality get marked red. I think this is becoming more and more easy to abuse. It also seems like specific to Tumblr there is this thing where trans men and nonbinary people specifically are getting marked red which makes me feel really confused and a bit unsafe??? I'll be uninstalling. This is why we can't have nice things...
edit: It also seems like POC are being targeted. Triple, quadruple yikes. - Оценено на 1 из 5от evilbunnytornado, 16 дней назадkeep seeing intersex people and people who say that trans men face oppression marked red and people who are honest to god using 'theyfab' marked green. useless at this point
- Оценено на 1 из 5от Joseph, 16 дней назадim far more likely to run into someone marked red who just happens to be not white, a trans man, intersex, or a combination of the 3 than an actual transphobe
- Оценено на 1 из 5от ambrolen, 17 дней назадIt's been showing more and more bias against trans people who talk about trans masc, nb, and intersex issues (probably more tbh) for years now, but it's getting so bad that I assume a Tumblr blog marked red speaks up for those groups rather than assuming they're a transphobe. I've been keeping it anyway to help me remember which news sites suck, but it's become a detriment. This could have been a good tool, but I guess the mods, or the creator, or both have decided to use it in bad faith against their own community.
- Оценено на 1 из 5от J-P, 17 дней назадThe users have bias against trans men, intersex people, and people of color. You have to experience your gender in a way that is "correct" to white transfemmes or else you get marked red.
- Оценено на 5 из 5от Пользователь Firefox 18992995, 19 дней назадkeep in mind all the 1 star reviews are transmisogynists lmao. good addon
- Оценено на 5 из 5от jackknifeJaws, 22 дня назадa good tool to find out who's a misogynistic (specifically transmisogynistic) weirdo.
im sorry trans women. - Оценено на 1 из 5от Lee, 22 дня назад"If it sounds too good to be true.": The description claims to target "transphobic/anti-LGBT" content, but it doesn't. Nonbinary, intersex, trans masc, and POC are consistently flagged red. It flags binary white trans women as green, even as they call for the deaths of the aforementioned groups. This is a racist, intersexist, enbyphobic addon. If you identify with any of these groups move on.
- Оценено на 5 из 5от Bimny, 24 дня назадIf anything this extension doesn't flag enough people. Transmisogynists are under reported. People giving 1 star and claiming its run by TERFs are just mad that they can't harass trans women with impunity and consider men more important than women.
- Оценено на 5 из 5от Alex Amelia Pine, 25 дней назадThe negative reviews are almost entirely review bombing. I use this all the time, and have never had a problem with false flags. If anything I find things that should be flagged one way or the other going without a flag at all. 9 times out of 10 if you look at the profile that got flagged, you'll find why within a minute of scrolling. The transphobes (usually transmisogynists specifically, but all kinds of transphobes) who get flagged red love to complain about how bigoted and inaccurate this extension is and how it can't be trusted, but then you look and see them spouting the most hateful rhetoric about trans people, plenty of them even trans themself. It's not a tool for exclusively marking transmisogyny, but transmisogyny is transphobia, and when fellow trans people are anti-transfeminist, they rightfully get flagged red. TL;DR it works great and has kept me safe from transphobes, remember to flag accurately and block liberally 👍
- Оценено на 4 из 5от Пользователь Firefox 18877928, месяц назад
- Оценено на 1 из 5от landsharkkidd, месяц назадI really loved this extension, especially when it came to people who might dog whistle their transphobia. But I've increasingly seen friends/people I follow who are either trans themselves (which, of coure, transphobic trans people exist, but this isn't the case here) or are ally's who get marked as red. This is genuinely heartbreaking, as this extension is something I've been using for years, and it was one of the extension I kept when I moved from Chrome to Firefox. But the lack of updates, and the fact that transphobes can use it against its purposes really sucks. I hope that the devs or someone else can pick up the pieces, but I think I'll uninstall this now.