Shqyrtime për AdNauseam
AdNauseam nga Daniel Howe
Shqyrtim nga TT
Vlerësuar me 4 yje nga 5 të mundshëm
nga TT, 2 vite më parëIt's honestly a 4-star addon, but I'm temporarily setting this to one star to get the dev's attention. Read on, and you'll see why:
It works great (for now,)and I realize it's Recommended by Mozilla, but I wanted to warn people about Google's increasingly weird TOS, and specifically, this addon's seemingly dangerous interactions with it.
When you allow this addon to run in the background, it clicks on "all ads" or "some ads," which for some reason causes Google to flag your account as "may be under 18." (Maybe it auto-clicked on a Polly Pocket ad? I dunno.)
The ambiguous wording here is, I suppose, by design. They're not accusing you of BEING underage, they're just saying maybe you are, maybe you aren't.
Of course, the only way to find out your account has been flagged in this way is to click the [+] button in the corner of an ad that Google knows darned well has nothing to do with your Recommended videos. Which means the only way you'll even become aware of it this phenomenon in the first place is by running Ad Nauseam, then turning it off again.
(Intriguingly, if you had Safe-Search turned off before you installed the plugin, becoming "maybe under 18" disables the Safe Mode button in a way that literally makes it impossible for you to enable it again. Is Google seriously trying to say that they both think you may be under 18, *and* that they're deliberately going to force you to see NSFW search results???)
The fact that the [+] only shows on ads that are drastically different from your Recommendeds shows that Google already knows exactly what it is doing, here. They're serving incongruous ads on purpose. The question is why?
It's unknown what Google's goals or long-term plan are, but combined with various other clauses in Google's TOS, this "may be under 18" phrase has some unfortunate implications:
The worst-case scenario I can imagine is, Google bans you, (that is, the user, the person, not the account,) from all of their platforms simultaneously, and also flags you in a database as some sort of child molester, ostensibly because you were over 18 when they served you your search results, but under 18 when you viewed them, and by clicking on the search results, you, an adult, were distributing NSFW content to yourself, a minor. And WEI rollout means they *might* have just enough information to track you as you move from account to account, so they could make it stick.
I doubt they'd have a legitimate legal case against anyone, since you literally can't be two ages at once. But if the goal is just to separate the internet into technological haves and have-nots, this is one excuse they could use to make sure anyone running AdNauseam ends up as a have-not, all the while telling regulators that the metrics say they banned a bunch of pedros.
That's just one of the baffling interpretations of the faux-legalease in these TOS that treats each user as a quantum superposition of their browsing behavior, rather than as a person.
(That said, they can also ban any user they want for "not being profitable enough." They added that gem in 2019. Which you'd think would be good enough to let them do away with all accounts that use ad-blockers, across the board, so I'm not sure what the goal of this stealth ad semi-shadowban is.)
I'd say "stay safe out there," but with the FBI demanding that literally everybody run an ad blocker, I'm not even sure I know what "safe" means anymore.
Not a complaint, just an observation. I would add one star if this situation could somehow be addressed by the addon. (But of course, it can't. That's the point.)
I'll set it back to 4 stars if the dev responds. He seems to take one-star reviews very seriously if past behavior is any indication. (Sorry for the inconvenience, Daniel. For what it's worth, I really like the use of negative space on your website.)
Also, apparently, for the guy above me, KOLJAAAA, it auto-clicked on Malware. Yikes! I wonder if Google is also doing THAT on purpose.
It works great (for now,)and I realize it's Recommended by Mozilla, but I wanted to warn people about Google's increasingly weird TOS, and specifically, this addon's seemingly dangerous interactions with it.
When you allow this addon to run in the background, it clicks on "all ads" or "some ads," which for some reason causes Google to flag your account as "may be under 18." (Maybe it auto-clicked on a Polly Pocket ad? I dunno.)
The ambiguous wording here is, I suppose, by design. They're not accusing you of BEING underage, they're just saying maybe you are, maybe you aren't.
Of course, the only way to find out your account has been flagged in this way is to click the [+] button in the corner of an ad that Google knows darned well has nothing to do with your Recommended videos. Which means the only way you'll even become aware of it this phenomenon in the first place is by running Ad Nauseam, then turning it off again.
(Intriguingly, if you had Safe-Search turned off before you installed the plugin, becoming "maybe under 18" disables the Safe Mode button in a way that literally makes it impossible for you to enable it again. Is Google seriously trying to say that they both think you may be under 18, *and* that they're deliberately going to force you to see NSFW search results???)
The fact that the [+] only shows on ads that are drastically different from your Recommendeds shows that Google already knows exactly what it is doing, here. They're serving incongruous ads on purpose. The question is why?
It's unknown what Google's goals or long-term plan are, but combined with various other clauses in Google's TOS, this "may be under 18" phrase has some unfortunate implications:
The worst-case scenario I can imagine is, Google bans you, (that is, the user, the person, not the account,) from all of their platforms simultaneously, and also flags you in a database as some sort of child molester, ostensibly because you were over 18 when they served you your search results, but under 18 when you viewed them, and by clicking on the search results, you, an adult, were distributing NSFW content to yourself, a minor. And WEI rollout means they *might* have just enough information to track you as you move from account to account, so they could make it stick.
I doubt they'd have a legitimate legal case against anyone, since you literally can't be two ages at once. But if the goal is just to separate the internet into technological haves and have-nots, this is one excuse they could use to make sure anyone running AdNauseam ends up as a have-not, all the while telling regulators that the metrics say they banned a bunch of pedros.
That's just one of the baffling interpretations of the faux-legalease in these TOS that treats each user as a quantum superposition of their browsing behavior, rather than as a person.
(That said, they can also ban any user they want for "not being profitable enough." They added that gem in 2019. Which you'd think would be good enough to let them do away with all accounts that use ad-blockers, across the board, so I'm not sure what the goal of this stealth ad semi-shadowban is.)
I'd say "stay safe out there," but with the FBI demanding that literally everybody run an ad blocker, I'm not even sure I know what "safe" means anymore.
Not a complaint, just an observation. I would add one star if this situation could somehow be addressed by the addon. (But of course, it can't. That's the point.)
I'll set it back to 4 stars if the dev responds. He seems to take one-star reviews very seriously if past behavior is any indication. (Sorry for the inconvenience, Daniel. For what it's worth, I really like the use of negative space on your website.)
Also, apparently, for the guy above me, KOLJAAAA, it auto-clicked on Malware. Yikes! I wonder if Google is also doing THAT on purpose.
Përgjigje zhvilluesi
postuar më 2 vite më parëHey TT, thank you for your extensive review, we had never come accross such an issue before, could you share with us some more info regarding it on the issue ticket I just created on our github page: https://github.com/dhowe/AdNauseam/issues/2439
We are discussing some possible implementation that can help deal with such unwanted ad visits here as well, feel free to share your opinion: https://github.com/dhowe/AdNauseam/issues/2440
We are discussing some possible implementation that can help deal with such unwanted ad visits here as well, feel free to share your opinion: https://github.com/dhowe/AdNauseam/issues/2440
667 shqyrtime
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga marzilla, 11 orë më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga BAMBAH, 20 orë më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga LemonMeringueTy, 4 ditë më parë
- Vlerësuar me 2 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 13248877 përdoruesi Firefox-i, një muaj më parëWorks extremely well on YouTube ads and similar things. Many other sites don't seem to be supported, though. Fragrantica, for example, is just a mess even with this installed. Blocking elements doesn't even matter because they reappear within seconds. I'd love to completely replace uBlock origin with this, but it seems like this has a lot of compatibility issues which uBlock doesn't have. Probably switching back soon.
EDIT: Ads also weren't being blocked at all on the Smithsonian site, which seems to use the same type of ad delivery as Fragrantica. I'd much rather have an adblocker which actually works. Messing with advertisers is awesome, but not at the cost of seeing ads on the internet again. Back to uBlock for me. - Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga TheLTrain, një muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Zazza, 2 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 17882170 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 2 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 3 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga insertname, 2 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 4 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 15323270 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 2 muaj më parëLove what the extension is doing. I understand that the filters are for advertisements, but in order for me to disable ublock, it'll require being able to block non ad, cosmetic elements to filter out like ratings for movies/shows. I use ublock to block annoying things or spoilers, as I don't want other opinions to paint a picture before I see something for myself.
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 18918959 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 2 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga chun, 2 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga dralsoM, 2 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 19487299 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 3 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Peroniko, 3 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Fabax, 3 muaj më parëbest adblocker on the website (well, it's based on ublock origin after all =D), purple like poison - that's what it is to digital advertising.
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga CrYzZ, 4 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 19603095 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 4 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Adude1, 4 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga CLumsyKnight, 4 muaj më parëI love this addon. Thanks for making this.
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga ingenarel (NeoJesus), 4 muaj më parëAbsolutely based, discovered the extension from Louis Rossmann, have been using it ever since and recommending it to everyone, I personally can't donate because of my own 0 funds, but i created a damn mozilla account just so that i can leave a review
keep up the good work folks, and i hope more people can follow your footsteps and create more ways to screw over corpos - Vlerësuar me 1 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 15292123 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 4 muaj më parëWorked great but for the last 2 days I'm having issues loading in YouTube - when the addon is active the page never loads. Until the issue is resolved I'm going back to uBlock
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 17609499 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 4 muaj më parëHonestly I'm still not sure about leaving ublock but this works great so far and messing with the advertisers is fucking great as well lmao
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 12814982 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 4 muaj më parëRichtige miese Erweiterung :D
uBlock mit Klickbot.
Die Privatsphäre leidet zwar dadurch, weshalb man das Addon nur in einem extra Browser nutzen sollte, aber es ist ein AdBlocker der zurück schießt.
Stresst zwar den guten Fuchs, wenn eine Webseite 20 Ads und mehr eingebaut hat, aber eine Stunde Server verursacht 200$ schaden. LoL.
Zudem wird man bei den Ad-Firmen wie Google oder Amazon mit der IP geblacklistet, wodurch weniger Werbung geladen wird.
(Man wird z.B. bei Twitch abgemeldet.) - Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Makis, 4 muaj më parë