Që të përdorni zgjerime për Android, do t’ju duhet Firefox-i për Android. Që të eksploroni shtesa Firefox-i për desktop, ju lutemi, vizitoni sajtin tonë për desktop.

Hyni
Ikonë shtese

Shqyrtime për DeArrow - Better Titles and Thumbnails on YouTube

DeArrow - Better Titles and Thumbnails on YouTube nga Ajay (SponsorBlock)

Vlerësuar me 4 yje nga 5 të mundshëm
5
194
4
34
3
14
2
15
1
47
304 shqyrtime
  • nga 17970984 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 2 vite më parë
    I think this add-on is a great idea, and like many other reviewers, I didn't really know I needed this until I turned it on.

    Currently, my only issue is that this app seems to really mess with the initial loading of videos, like it will stutter or not start in the first 10~20 seconds before returning to normal performance.

    This will only get better as more people start contributing to the process, but even now, not being exposed 24/7 to clickbait and other means to tug at your attention span makes a world of difference.

    Edit: Thank you for the response. It seems thumbnail generation service is back online, and as long as local generation performance can be improved, I think that might be the better long term solution, but I'm not here to tell you how to run the add-on.

    Përgjigje zhvilluesi

    postuar më 2 vite më parë
    The thumbnail generation service I'm running has gone down to due a storage issue, so it is falling back to local generation, which is probably causing those issues. I'll look into making the local generation work better in the future when outages happen.
  • nga OJ, 2 vite më parë
    I am just thanking because this exist.
  • nga Redempt, 2 vite më parë
    Does what it says on the tin, developer does a good job. Wish it had more community contributions but that will come with time. Love that it's open source, keep up the good work

    Përgjigje zhvilluesi

    postuar më 2 vite më parë
    thanks :)
  • nga 13491077 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 2 vite më parë
  • nga Charlie S, 2 vite më parë
    I do not agree that there should be a pay wall for late adopters. That makes it more difficult to get good crowd sourcing metrics, which is required for good performance.

    Përgjigje zhvilluesi

    postuar më 2 vite më parë
    The idea is to have an easy enough free access system to not cause any issues like that, but time will tell how it works out
  • nga Dark Moyan, 2 vite më parë
    I never knew I need this but now I really need this. I just hope you will add Original vs custom/random thumbnail so we could see the original and the random one.

    Përgjigje zhvilluesi

    postuar më 2 vite më parë
    Of you hover the title, there is a button to swap. You can make it always appear in the options
  • nga Saturn9, 2 vite më parë
  • nga hoggys2much, 2 vite më parë
    Total utter garbage! Tried it and Youtube completely DIED on me. Pages were still trying to load even after 5 minutes. Nothing worked, I had to close down all my Youtube tabs and it slowed down Firefox something rotten. I have deleted this utter garbage from add-ons. Do not use.

    Përgjigje zhvilluesi

    postuar më 2 vite më parë
    Edit: the update to fix this has been released

    As described in an earlier reply, I am current working on a fix for improved performance on Firefox. I should have it out today or tomorrow :)
  • nga EcoRadium, 2 vite më parë
  • nga misterwu99, 2 vite më parë
  • nga Claudiu, 2 vite më parë
  • nga Eason, 2 vite më parë
    DeArrow and SponsorBlock made my YouTube experience so much better!
  • nga DeAndre Queary, 2 vite më parë
    Seems to be working. It's by the same dev as Sponsor Block so im keeping it. 👌🏾
  • nga Throwawayaccount, 2 vite më parë
    This addon most definitely has potential! I find that video's have started buffering... if i click at the video bar on the right I see the video tiles slowly appear. Either way I will keep trying this addon and if the buffering gets bad put it on the sideline and check back on it. Either way 4/5 stars buds! Nice job!

    Edit: Thanks for the update! I do understand that it is in a 'Alpha/Beta' stage. I made an account just to give a 'Bug' or 'RFC' or 'Feedback' and once gain thank you for your effort!

    Përgjigje zhvilluesi

    postuar më 2 vite më parë
    Edit: the update to fix this has been released

    Still working out some issues, so I haven't released it yet, but the next update should help fix this by switching how the thumbnails are rendered on the page (By using Image elements instead of Canvas elements)
  • nga 15704348 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 2 vite më parë
  • nga Pedro, 2 vite më parë
  • nga grvb3x, 2 vite më parë
    Removing the clickbait from Youtube...brilliant, love it, makes Youtube a far more enjoyable and focused experience. Thanks Ajay!
  • nga 17940722 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 2 vite më parë
  • nga dzamie, 2 vite më parë
    It's so refreshing to not be bombarded by clickbait thumbnails. Plus, the occasional rewritten video title is nice (though I enjoy the ability to temporarily see the originals). The only issue is that it takes longer to load the new thumbnails, but honestly that's not much of a problem.
  • nga Carlosgs , 2 vite më parë
  • nga display name, 2 vite më parë
    Great idea. Though I am surprised that Tom Scott's channel was picked as a demonstration, as he is not a particularly bad offender in this respect, to the point where I personally do not mind having his original thumbnails and titles.

    If you're aiming at something clickbaity, yet still informative enough to be worth spending time on redacting, maybe show, I dunno, LegalEagle? TLDR News? Linus Tech Tips? Karl Jobst?

    Përgjigje zhvilluesi

    postuar më 2 vite më parë
    Very recently, Tom Scott and CGP Grey have started going through their entire backlog and changing titles and thumbnails to be more attention grabbing and vague. Channels doing things like this are a heavy inspiration for this extension.

    It's not just the Linus Tech Tips or the Mr Beasts of the world doing algorithm optimized titles and thumbnails now. Even really great channels like Tom Scott, CGP Grey, and Kurzgesagt are falling for the trap now.

    And I don't blame them! That's what's needed to survive on the platform these days. It's a race to the bottom.

    DeArrow hopes to solve this. DeArrow puts everyone on a level playing field. There is no race to the bottom since no one is allowed to be algorithmically optimized. It pauses the race, and let's the true best videos rise to the top.
  • nga p4t4, 2 vite më parë
    Maks youtube functionally better
  • nga Zack Bowden, 2 vite më parë
  • nga 15923203 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 2 vite më parë
    Great idea, but it slows down way too much. Especially on watch history page. It consumes my entire bandwith looking at task managers networking tab, above 800 mbps

    Përgjigje zhvilluesi

    postuar më 2 vite më parë
    Edit: The update I talked about is now released, so this should be fixed :)

    Thanks!

    So, there are two ways thumbnail generation works. One is via asking the server for one, and one is via downloading part of the video locally. Right now it tries both and stops when the first one loads.

    Next update, I am going to change that behavior to always only use the server one, and only try local generation if the server hasn't responded in some time.

    I also noticed a bug where sometimes local generation downloads the video multiple times, which might be amplifying the issue.

    So, hopefully this issue will be fixed in the next update and you can try again then! thanks!
  • nga merp, 2 vite më parë