This has gone from a useful add-on to one that marks anyone who talks about transphobia outside of a very narrow white-centric transfem focused band as transphobic. Its disappointing, and saddening to see

i really like shinigami eyes..... when its not used to call trans and intersex people transphobic. i cannot tell you how many times ive seen someone marked as trans unfriendly on tumblr and then i check their account and its because theyre talking about the issues that trans and intersex people face within queer spaces, and then people who are openly transmisogynistic wont be marked at all. its so ridiculous and the extension is barely useful now. i dont want to be reblogging shit from cryptoterfs and plain old bigots without realizing and spreading their blog to more people, but now i still have to go digging to see if theyre actually transphobic or if theyre just being dogpiled

Ironically transphobic against trans men and intersex people and silences them. There is no hate campaign, trans men and Intersex people are being silenced for speaking out on being oppressed. That is textbook transphobia.

I'm a transfem who primarily uses this on tumblr. This plugin used to be great for sniffing out transphobes, but lately I've found myself having to double-check whether pages are marked red correctly or not, because more often than not they're not actually transphobes and are just users who are intersex or transmasc and speaking up about their experiences. This plugin is being used to fuel inter-community strife that benefits no one and makes us all weaker. I know it's transfem users and transfem moderators who are doing this, and frankly I'm pretty disappointed in my sisters. If we can't stick together in times like these, when we're in the most danger we've been in since the 1930s, it's no wonder our rights lag behind everyone else in the acronym.

I've had Shinigami Eyes installed on my browsers for almost the past decade, and in its early years it was extremely helpful for rooting out radfems and the like. Unfortunately, over the past year or so there's been so many false flags, especially against trans men, that the extension is practically useless. The guidelines do state that being trans does not exempt someone from transphobia, yet people are being flagged red for talking about basically any aspect of transphobia and intersex experiences other than transmisogyny, while actual TERFs and other transphobes have been marked green. It's honestly kind of sad to see how far this extension has fallen

Seeing transandrophobia truthers constantly getting marked red as if they were on the same level as actual transphobes makes this extension useless to me on certain sites. Let us at least see why someone was marked red.

There are so many people who are marked red for just talking about the experiences with different aspects of transphobia and intersexism within the community; the extension has been weaponized by bad actors. This weaponization seems to be backed by the extension's creators.

I would like to see the post/comment/something that caused whomever to receive a red or green rating. Obviously hateful TERFs on twitter are going to be red, I can figure out why usually in the tweet I come across. But, I'll often find some random person on like, Reddit, that's red and want to know what they did. Usually, I don't have enough time to figure it out, or they've posted so much that I just can't find anything relevant. Having some context (when available) is essential so we can make our own judgement calls and contribute to making this extension as best as it can be.

Hello. I am transfeminine. I ask you read this review before continuing to read any others.

Many of the people rating this as "five stars" claim transmisogyny and "review bombing."

It is not review bombing. Most, if not all, of the one-star reviews are valid concerns and I have witnessed the things the one-star reviews are talking about with my own eyes. The people giving out one star reviews are not being transmisogynist. The fact that my own sisters in the trans community will claim such of people actually having grievances and struggles of their own is a fact that disgusts me.

Most of the one-star reviews are discussing experiencing "transandrophobia," intersexism, and even racism at the hands of the developers of this extension. They speak of many people being completely, unfairly, and unjustly marked red, and I have seen this happening more and more often, and I find more and more people being marked green purely on the basis of being a trans woman.

This is actually a one-star review, but I wanted to put this here to challenge the people in the 5-star section having the disgusting gall to call our trans siblings "transmisogynist" for the mere fact that they are not trans women themselves.

And if one such reviewer is reading this...

Do better. I know you can. Fix your hearts.

has been marking intersex and transmasc specific discussions as anti-trans, especially on tumblr, along with marking terfs and intersexophobic blogs as safe. might be useful outside of tumblr but no longer useable.

basically useless now, not reliable anymore

this extension is an excellent flag that signals to me that i need to dig deeper into a person's stances on trans people before sharing their content online. contrary to many of these reviews, the moderation is extremely consistent; it is simply that whoever's doing the moderation is focused on preventing transmisogyny (as they should be). the website itself states, "Don't assume someone is not transphobic just because they are trans or non-binary themselves." every single trans person i've seen marked red on shinigami eyes or complaining about a false flag has indeed had transmisogynistic rhetoric on their blog. this extension isn't wrongfully marking anyone; you simply disagree with the moderator(s) when it comes to what is or isn't transphobic. personally, this extension has helped me block terfs i see in my notifications so that my posts don't gain traction in their circles, which has been massively useful over the years. thank you shinigami eyes!

is it really a smear campaign if many users, such as myself, were unaware of the wrongfully-marked-red accounts of the past year or so, and are only recently learning that this is a widespread issue that isn't being addressed properly? i now know there's no point in trying to address it, as the extension's owners are in on it.

you there, random user looking for an easier way to avoid transphobes online. were you thinking about using it? don't. it was good once. it no longer is.

Both the creator and many users are using this add-on to promote transphobia instead of warn against it. Do not trust. Do not use.

devs who run the master list of green and red r marking intersex and transmasc ppl as "anti-trans", is discriminatory towards intersex ppl. trans ppl (perisex trans women in this case) r not immune to prejudice and it rlly shows here. dont use this extension, it lost its use once it started discriminating against intersex and transmasc ppl

has its uses, got recommended by this really cool cis dude. it's always a delight to stumble upon a celebrity marked green when i least expect it. no clue what the recent enmity's about, this thang makes the web a little less scary......

Okay I'm seriously confused but I'm not gonna trust what's being written these don't sound like real people they sound like bots or republicans masquerading as trans or whatever either way I really don't care what a bunch boxes of text are saying until I see it for myself I'm not trusting you