Shqyrtime për DeArrow - Better Titles and Thumbnails on YouTube
DeArrow - Better Titles and Thumbnails on YouTube nga Ajay (SponsorBlock)
Shqyrtim nga 18192038 përdoruesi Firefox-i
Vlerësuar me 4 yje nga 5 të mundshëm
nga 18192038 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 2 vite më parëhas a tendency to replace video titles with content descriptions, which, while good, does spoil the twist of the video in some cases (see hbomberguy's robloxoof.mp3 video) and can end up removing thumbnail art that is more of a title card than clickbait.
biggest suggestion would be to allow for a setting to remove clickbait while allowing actual titles to stay, but then you're asking a democratic userbase to deal with nuance sooo
overall ok first impression, good job Ajay Ramachandran.
edit: tbh, it's more funny than annoying to me
biggest suggestion would be to allow for a setting to remove clickbait while allowing actual titles to stay, but then you're asking a democratic userbase to deal with nuance sooo
overall ok first impression, good job Ajay Ramachandran.
edit: tbh, it's more funny than annoying to me
Përgjigje zhvilluesi
postuar më 2 vite më parëI recommend using "Default to original details" in the extension settings for your preferences
316 shqyrtime
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga chewygum, 9 ditë më parë
- Vlerësuar me 3 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Ritchie, 10 ditë më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Glen, 15 ditë më parë
- Vlerësuar me 1 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 19110817 përdoruesi Firefox-i, një muaj më parëA massively over-engineered solution compared to something like Clickbait Remover. Why does this require the Sponsorblock model instead of just giving you semi-random screenshots? Why all this complexity?
I don't think there's any reason other than the developer wishing to justify monetizing crowd-sourced software.
EDIT: response to developer - I would wager that the vast majority of this addon's users don't care about the title change feature (indeed, I quickly disabled it). I also don't see how Clickbait Remover predating Arrow excuses Arrow being over-engineered - if anything, that makes it worse (a simple solution was demonstrated, yet it was decided to build an incredibly convoluted alternative)Përgjigje zhvilluesi
postuar më 16 ditë më parëClickbait remover is a great extension that was made before dearrow. If you prefer that simple approach, it's made for you
The crowdsourcing in dearrow is more about titles than thumbnails, which is something clickbait remover is not able to deal with.
Response to edit: I'm not sure I understand your point. If you don't think crowdsourcing is beneficial to you, you should use the other extension. The whole point of this extension is for the crowdsourcing, so most people using this extension are do have those enabled. - Vlerësuar me 2 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga random user, një muaj më parëAwkward semi-paid scheme, especially for a crowdsourced project. That alone makes me not want to contribute since the dev might at an point decide to remove access.
The replaced thumbnails are very hit and miss. Replacing clickbait is one thing, but this extension just want to replace all of them indiscriminatingly, removing useful information. Quite a bit are literally just replaced with blank images or other junk...Përgjigje zhvilluesi
postuar më 16 ditë më parëBy default, most thumbnails are replaced with random screenshots to try to let you get a sense of what the video is like. This can be changed in the settings to show the original thumbnails instead of you prefer them.
All the crowdsourced data is public and under a creative commons license (https://sponsor.ajay.app/database). The code is also fully open source under the GPL. The magic of open source is that anyone can continue the project or fork it to their own desire. - Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Bryn, një muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga brockar, një muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga ta44, një muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 19094068 përdoruesi Firefox-i, një muaj më parëA great addon that de-clickbaits youtube. Only downside is that after using it for some time, you realise that most of what reaches the front page is just slop. I happily paid for DeArrow as it has made the youtube experience much better for filtering good content out of the slop.
- Vlerësuar me 1 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 19092967 përdoruesi Firefox-i, një muaj më parëAggressively asks for payment despite 99% of its value being derived from the community that contributes the titles/thumbnails __for free__. Imagine if Wikipedia tried to charge a monthly subscription...
Asking for donations is one thing, and you certainly deserve some money for the work you've done here, but there's a difference between politely asking for a donation and blocking somebody's path until they shove you out of the way - Vlerësuar me 1 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 19001582 përdoruesi Firefox-i, një muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 4 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Seumas, 2 muaj më parëLike its sister extension (SponsorBlock), DeArrow changes the game when it comes to experiencing Youtube. If only were were a solution on mobile and elsewhere, too. Crowdsourced video titles means no more hyperbole, obnoxious formatting, and outright lying or baiting. And when you *do* run into those things, it feels good improving them so that others with the extension can benefit from a clearer and cleaner experience. I almost never pay or donate for extensions (though I have), but I immediately did so for DeArrow and SponsorBlock. I hope these extensions both grow in popularity, so even more videos are improved at a faster rate.
The only reason I knocked a star off of this review is that if I don't QUICKLY add the title when the input interface is open, it will always kill my entire browser (Zen Browser on Windows 11 usually). Everything -- all windows, tabs, etc -- the whole browser just hangs and the only way to get it working again is to kill the process and launch again. It happens so quickly that I have to type my title out in notepad, then copy it so that as soon as I open the input interface, I can immediately paste it in and hit the submit button.
However, if using it passively (not contributing -- just getting the benefit of better titles), it has no apparent negative impact. I would contribute more frequently if it were more stable, but it is otherwise terrific. - Vlerësuar me 3 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga walu, 2 muaj më parëthe thumbnail replacement is great, i don't use the title replacement. unfortunately, whenever i click on the "open submission menu" pencil icon, firefox freezes entirely and i have to kill and restart it :(
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga kurimir, 2 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga calzone, 2 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 5DaysN1ght, 2 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 3 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Silent Spud, 3 muaj më parëWas pretty great until submissions just stopped working entirely for a long time. Here's hoping the dev can find a solution
Përgjigje zhvilluesi
postuar më 3 muaj më parëSubmissions from new users have been restricted because someone is automatically creating many bots and sending malicious titles across youtube. We are working to slowly allow newer users to submit again - Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga klementine des pêches, 4 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 1 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga SimoX9, 4 muaj më parëIt's paid, there is no option to use it free, the description is lying, best you get is 'free' 6 hours before it lockes you from using it..
Përgjigje zhvilluesi
postuar më 4 muaj më parëClick "I can't/don't want to pay" at the bottom of the page - Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 18177036 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 4 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga rafafunt, 4 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Imprest, 5 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 2 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga 15998822 përdoruesi Firefox-i, 5 muaj më parëWeird plug in that doesn't really work until you figure out if the author wants to be paid or not. It's only $1 (I think), and offers the option of just either having a trial or using it for free, but neither of the last options worked.
I'm sure this is a great idea, but I couldn't get it to work to check if I liked it. Just make it paid for or not please, I don't want to have to faff about trying to get it to work. - Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga ramiel, 5 muaj më parë
- Vlerësuar me 5 yje nga 5 të mundshëmnga Morgoz, 5 muaj më parëWorks great with English content however since it is crowdsourced when it's not popular in certain countries or certain languages it's really hard to find an usage. Still, a great extension for English YouTube videos.