Recensioner för Firefox Multi-Account Containers
Firefox Multi-Account Containers av Firefox
Recension av Felix, the “Upright Bassist”
Betygsatt 3 av 5
av Felix, the “Upright Bassist”, för 5 år sedanRichtig scheiße, denn das fördert Clutter und Chaos bei (zu) vielen Tabs und Fenstern:
Nach Auswahl bei einem Tab von „Always open this site in …“* öffnet sich
1. ohne Warnung/Hinweis
• ein (anscheinend) Klon des Tabs**, und zwar
• dort, wo gerade Aktivität war, also schlimmstenfalls, wo er im Leben nicht hingehört.
Das könnte ich noch verschmerzen, auch wenn es nervt. Aber
2. — wieder ohne Warnung/Hinweis! —
• es öffnen sich (alle? zumindest sehr, sehr viele) weitere(n) Inzidienzien dieses Tabs; in meinem Falle waren es zuerst hunderte, weil ich zuerst die dringendste Herausforderung an Privatheit angehen wollte.
Übrigens zunächst mit der (dann ziemlich) dussligen Warnung unter dem Titel “Multi-Account Containers Confirm Navigation”* mit dem Inhalt “Open this site in your assigned container? You asked Firefox to always open CarmaChamleon for this site: (…URL…) Would you still like to open in this current container?
[ ] Remember my decision for this site
[Open in Current Container] [Open in CarmaChamleon]”*.
Und dann noch einer… noch einer… noch… noch…noch… und nochundnochundnochundnochundnoch — und… so weiter.
Das erinnert mich an Windows-Installation im Vergleich zu Mac (früher jedenfalls): Windows fragt jeweils zu verschiedenen Zeitpunkten Dinge ab, statt diese vorab in einem Rutsch zu klären…
Suggestions to the developers:
Please consider those people who — like me — are “tab hoarders”.
—> warn that possibly hundreds of tabs will open when making that choice (at least once, with remember of course), or better
—> find another way of dealing with that situation:
• open in place, why not the same tab anyway? At least in the same window!!! — I (try to) put order into the placing of tabs in different windows, so don't mess with that, please…
• and… well no “and”, that would heal the problem of cluttery and confusion.
In the meantime, address us “tab hoarders” at least by putting up a warning on first usage, better yet a set of instructions — maybe there's a better way to set it up without annoyance and confusion?
Bear in mind, we might have fairly slow computers still in use, so when testing, consider that as well…
Thank you.
And, another thing:
translation.
With German, I offer help. My English is, hm, okay; my German is excellent, I love to use precise expressions that are still easy to understand.
* Übersetzung?!?!? — Deutsch ist nun nicht eine Sprache, die bloß von 20 versprengten Individuen in weit verstreuten Hütten in der Tundra oder dem Regenwald gesprochen wird…!
Ich würde auch dabei helfen, da ich auch Englisch recht gut beherrsche.
Nach Auswahl bei einem Tab von „Always open this site in …“* öffnet sich
1. ohne Warnung/Hinweis
• ein (anscheinend) Klon des Tabs**, und zwar
• dort, wo gerade Aktivität war, also schlimmstenfalls, wo er im Leben nicht hingehört.
Das könnte ich noch verschmerzen, auch wenn es nervt. Aber
2. — wieder ohne Warnung/Hinweis! —
• es öffnen sich (alle? zumindest sehr, sehr viele) weitere(n) Inzidienzien dieses Tabs; in meinem Falle waren es zuerst hunderte, weil ich zuerst die dringendste Herausforderung an Privatheit angehen wollte.
Übrigens zunächst mit der (dann ziemlich) dussligen Warnung unter dem Titel “Multi-Account Containers Confirm Navigation”* mit dem Inhalt “Open this site in your assigned container? You asked Firefox to always open CarmaChamleon for this site: (…URL…) Would you still like to open in this current container?
[ ] Remember my decision for this site
[Open in Current Container] [Open in CarmaChamleon]”*.
Und dann noch einer… noch einer… noch… noch…noch… und nochundnochundnochundnochundnoch — und… so weiter.
Das erinnert mich an Windows-Installation im Vergleich zu Mac (früher jedenfalls): Windows fragt jeweils zu verschiedenen Zeitpunkten Dinge ab, statt diese vorab in einem Rutsch zu klären…
Suggestions to the developers:
Please consider those people who — like me — are “tab hoarders”.
—> warn that possibly hundreds of tabs will open when making that choice (at least once, with remember of course), or better
—> find another way of dealing with that situation:
• open in place, why not the same tab anyway? At least in the same window!!! — I (try to) put order into the placing of tabs in different windows, so don't mess with that, please…
• and… well no “and”, that would heal the problem of cluttery and confusion.
In the meantime, address us “tab hoarders” at least by putting up a warning on first usage, better yet a set of instructions — maybe there's a better way to set it up without annoyance and confusion?
Bear in mind, we might have fairly slow computers still in use, so when testing, consider that as well…
Thank you.
And, another thing:
translation.
With German, I offer help. My English is, hm, okay; my German is excellent, I love to use precise expressions that are still easy to understand.
* Übersetzung?!?!? — Deutsch ist nun nicht eine Sprache, die bloß von 20 versprengten Individuen in weit verstreuten Hütten in der Tundra oder dem Regenwald gesprochen wird…!
Ich würde auch dabei helfen, da ich auch Englisch recht gut beherrsche.
7 884 recensioner
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av AR Rehman, för 13 timmar sedan
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av oo, för 3 dagar sedanFucking amazing! Was able to completely neuter Reddit's tracking so hard the Admins didn't know what the fuck hit them or what to do about it!
Power to the users! If a site is giving you grief? Chuck 'em in a tiny little bubble and tell 'em to fuck off!
Love this addon - it has all the functions you need to ringfence correctly - isolated sites can click out and you'll have all your normal cookies back - but the isolated target is none the wiser.
No hard work - set and forget, and done.
It's this easy.
I'll be doing similar for other sites - Shopping, Social media, Youtube... You name it. - Betygsatt 5 av 5av Firefox-användare 15358174, för 4 dagar sedanThe click target for Container management could be a tad larger for repeatable precision, Otherwise works as described. Android Implementation is much appreciated.
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av Steve, för 4 dagar sedanI just love what this extension does, preventing cross-talk between activated Container tabs! There is one, rather large, caveat, however, in that when initially setting up a URL in a designated Container, it easily completed, and it looks like you're done! BUT... the next time you use that URL (say you Bookmarked it), you are presented with a Container verification screen, where you have to say, "Yes, I actually DO WANT to use the Container that I thought that I already HAD set up!" What this means is that once you setup a URL to a Container, you have to immediately TRY that URL (possibly Bookmarked) to answer that verification page. THEN...everything works as expected. I consider it an inconvenience, but once you are used to jumping thru the hoops, its 2nd nature. And that does not detract from the purpose or function of the extension!
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av Firefox-användare 14991062, för 5 dagar sedanWorks well for my use (on a single machine). I haven't used the sync-option! Other reviews report it is buggy...
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av Firefox-användare 15356034, för 5 dagar sedan
- Betygsatt 4 av 5av fabioescolastico, för 6 dagar sedanAjuda muito quem precisa acessar vários de logins diferentes, mas a sincronia tem problemas.
- Betygsatt 1 av 5av majesticmini, för 10 dagar sedanIt was miraculous to use, but Mozilla does not care to develop or run anything without illegal corporations telling them what to do. Who agrees? Is the Internet not a conspiracy?
- Betygsatt 1 av 5av Firefox-användare 13835821, för 12 dagar sedanIrresponsible to have this extension published and available with such dire bugs. Whatever you do, DO NOT turn on Sync for this extension. You'll end up wiping out your entire configuration, your containers, your site rules, everything.
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av DDB, för 13 dagar sedan
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av Firefox-användare 14515734, för 13 dagar sedan
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av KurChr, för 14 dagar sedanNeeded to have multiple Web Outlook email accounts open simultaneously. Worked great. If pinned the accounts came back up without logging in again if Firefox exited and restarted. Would be absolutely perfect for me if the accounts came back up after a Restart.
- Betygsatt 3 av 5av Randomfox, för 14 dagar sedanDoesn't work well containing Google, can't sign in on gemini.google.com
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av Firefox-användare 19625591, för 14 dagar sedan
- Betygsatt 1 av 5av 0x666c697473, för 17 dagar sedanGuaranteed to silently drop containers in the middle of your workflow, with no github interest in even acknowledging the problem.
- Betygsatt 1 av 5av spindog, för 17 dagar sedansyncing is pointless. i'm done setting up site lists every time it resets when logging in on new devices.
- Betygsatt 1 av 5av Davide, för 18 dagar sedanThe Firefox Sync integration is horrible - it keeps merging back old changes. Container settings get reverted, and old removed containers come back...
- Betygsatt 3 av 5av Sean Critz, för 19 dagar sedanThis extension needs some work before it fits the concept. In situations where multiple accounts need to be managed on the same website (using multiple microsoft accounts for different clients, for instance) , it is generally not usable. The following workflow breaks it:
- Open tab in X container, login to a service
- Service uses redirects to authenticate, container extension grabs those redirects and loses the container status or changes the container status, breaking the login flow or putting a different login into the context
Additionally, there does not seem to be an option to remove a site from a container preference, once added. - Betygsatt 5 av 5av René, för 19 dagar sedanDe ideale manier om met meerdere accounts en een domein te werken zonder van profiel te hoeven wisselen.
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av Steve S, för 21 dagar sedan
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av Firefox-användare 14376762, för 22 dagar sedanWorks well for seperating my tracked internet history, without needing to setup a second Firefox Profile & Mozilla Account. This in addition to the Facebook, Google & Twitter Containers help keep those 3 from tying everywhere I go on the 'net to my accounts.
- Betygsatt 4 av 5av Firefox-användare 13252902, för 25 dagar sedanReally helps at keeping some of the problematic sites contained. Could use some polishing but very useful addition.
- Betygsatt 5 av 5av fazlan, för en månad sedanthis is the god extension for me. my life saver please continue. dont stop ever. i love you firefox
- Betygsatt 3 av 5av Mackintosh´s, för en månad sedanPlease change environment bonds to Deep Links instead of only Top Level Domains. Ask whether the container should always open up when the current deep link is opened or whenever any site of the top level domain is opened.