Shinigami Eyes 的评价
Shinigami Eyes 作者: Shinigami Eyes
556 条评价
- 评分 1 / 5来自 marquesa.loving.kitsune, 3 个月前why are trans men and poc trans people flagged red over talking about their own experiences? why are intersex people flagged red for talking about their experiences?
i thought this addon was supposed to help trans people protect themselves from transphobes but it really is being used to protect only white trans women's and their fragile egos
time to go back to ye olden times (or what everyone who doesn't use their pc for social media does anyways) - 评分 1 / 5来自 kittyacelia, 3 个月前
- 评分 1 / 5来自 Firefox 用户 18125561, 3 个月前
- for those unaware, theres been a lot of intracommunity discourse about transmascs, and an attempt to find words to describe our unique experience with transphobia. a certain subset of the trans community has taken to calling every attempt to do so transmisogyny, and it appears the mod team have taken that side too. many of the users marked green are outright hateful about transmen, using words like "zippertits", "birthday boy" and "theyfab" to demean us and other members of the community who agree with us. there are also now a bunch of users unfairly marked as red, despite not being transphobic at all, and only stating that transmascs can be as oppressed as transfems. i have also heard of intersex people being unfairly marked, but i do not feel well read enough to fully get into that. overall its a huge shame this has been allowed to happen.
- the moderation team has completely lost their scruples when it comes to who counts as "transphobic" or not, often marking intersex people and their advocates, trans men who speak about their experiences with transphobia, trans people of colors, and non-dysphoric trans people as "transphobic" for no reason other than to be aligned with the "right" side of extremely online discourse that has no place in the real world.
- This app specifically says it is intended to help the transgender community. Things have recently changed where it now has chosen to exclude members of that community.
Trying to hold trans-femininity as the sole beacon to guide this project has hurt and left behind most of those it claimed to help, many of those who helped this tool grow.
If this app chooses to hurt all other genders for simply not worshiping the feminine, is it any better than a TERF tool? A group of transphobes who already villainize anything remotely masculine or non-feminine?
The transgender community, and more importantly the LGBTQ+ community as a whole, needs to accept that we may not all have the same personal definitions of gender, and that's okay. There will never be blanket terms to cover every nuance, we cannot limit ourselves, and we should never try to force others to exist within strict boxes or binaries.
Someone venting about their lived experience is not an attack on yours. It is petty and childish when you refuse to listen to your community and outright shun some groups like intersex individuals.
This add-on used to be one that brought us together, to help see others as part of a found family. If the future of it is now simply to be a club and to harm the reputation of others simply to only give oneself more attention, consider starting a vitriolic rant youtube channel instead.
Currently this app has been corrupted by transphobia. Yes, transgender people can be transphobic, especially when you choose to align your identity with exclusionary rhetoric and spout the same bioessentialism as TERFs and other bigots.
You really disappoint many of us, and should be doing better. - 评分 1 / 5来自 Firefox 用户 18739377, 4 个月前used to be helpful, has now devolved into punishing intersex activists for talking about their experiences. would be useful with more rigorous moderation that didn’t encourage infighting
- 评分 1 / 5来自 Firefox 用户 18739364, 4 个月前
- 评分 1 / 5来自 Clown-Hour, 4 个月前Used to be good/decent but now is just for the moderators of the tool to exclude any opinions they dislike, rendering this tool the "these are the people WE feel are valid" tool
- 评分 1 / 5来自 Valley_Foods, 4 个月前
- 评分 1 / 5来自 Firefox 用户 18738343, 4 个月前while it used to be. uhm. decent I guess? and a unique concept, the last few months the moderator team I guess took a u turn, because transphobes are green and actual trans people are red and it doesnt help distinguish who is safe and who isnt anymore. if anything it makes things worse by confusing everyone. maybe try following your own guidelines, moderators. jeez.
- 评分 1 / 5来自 PeraNormal, 4 个月前Purports to differentiate between trans-friendly and anti-trans people/organizations, but it has become a tool used for infighting.
- 评分 1 / 5来自 allsnarker, 4 个月前used to be good but started flagging people that support intersex folks/transmascs as terfs and tbh im not here for that.
- 评分 1 / 5来自 Firefox 用户 18738016, 4 个月前Uninstalled after multiple instances of people getting wrongfully flagged red, failure to adress the controversy. do better.
- 评分 1 / 5来自 damiendoodles, 4 个月前it was great at first but then it started marking trans-masculine, nonbinary and intersex people as transphobic just for being themselves and talking about their experiences. it also marked any trans-masc, nonbinary, and intersex allies/advocates as transphobic.
very disappointing, and i hope the team behind this fixes this very soon.