Sticky Containers 的評論
Sticky Containers 作者: David Lynch
Cyberknight 所留下的評論
評價 3 分，滿分 5 分
來自 Cyberknight，7 年前This add-on makes dealing with containers much easier, but it requires a lot of polishing.
I just found three bugs:
1) Customisation mode cannot be activated, because the add-on tries to "contain" it, what causes it to break (the add-on should check if it's the customisation tab that's being opened and avoid trying to "contain" it). Other built-in Pages work fine (about:config, about:preferences and so on). The bug only shows when the customisation is activated on a window with containers.
2) Control+N or File -> New Window opens a new container tab, instead of a new window! Once again, the bug only shows up when the commands are used on a window with containers. When done on a window without ANY containers, a new window is normally created (it doesn't matter if the active tab is "uncontained"). If, for instance, no window is uncontained, the is no way to create new windows (dragging a tab out of its window, luckily, still work, so it's possible to "produce" new "uncontained" windows by creating an empty tab, which will be contained, drag it out to create a new window, then switch the container of that new tab with Switch Container Plus, which is currently the only add-on able to change containers of empty tabs). Too much trouble just to create a window, but still possible.
3) When recovering from a crash, ALL tabs on ALL windows are "contained" (kind of randomly, depending on the first contained tab Firefox restores (it doesn't have to load it, just its presence in any window is enough to "contaminate" all other tabs). It's, in a word, disastrous, as all tabs change their containers (even uncontained ones), messing with logged in accounts, changing site preferences and whatnot.
Currently, this add-on is unusable (yes, it works fine enough while everything is running smooth, but then it may mess up everything in the event of a crash or restart).
I just found three bugs:
1) Customisation mode cannot be activated, because the add-on tries to "contain" it, what causes it to break (the add-on should check if it's the customisation tab that's being opened and avoid trying to "contain" it). Other built-in Pages work fine (about:config, about:preferences and so on). The bug only shows when the customisation is activated on a window with containers.
2) Control+N or File -> New Window opens a new container tab, instead of a new window! Once again, the bug only shows up when the commands are used on a window with containers. When done on a window without ANY containers, a new window is normally created (it doesn't matter if the active tab is "uncontained"). If, for instance, no window is uncontained, the is no way to create new windows (dragging a tab out of its window, luckily, still work, so it's possible to "produce" new "uncontained" windows by creating an empty tab, which will be contained, drag it out to create a new window, then switch the container of that new tab with Switch Container Plus, which is currently the only add-on able to change containers of empty tabs). Too much trouble just to create a window, but still possible.
3) When recovering from a crash, ALL tabs on ALL windows are "contained" (kind of randomly, depending on the first contained tab Firefox restores (it doesn't have to load it, just its presence in any window is enough to "contaminate" all other tabs). It's, in a word, disastrous, as all tabs change their containers (even uncontained ones), messing with logged in accounts, changing site preferences and whatnot.
Currently, this add-on is unusable (yes, it works fine enough while everything is running smooth, but then it may mess up everything in the event of a crash or restart).
35 筆評論
- 評價 1 分，滿分 5 分來自 Firefox 使用者 12719365，8 個月前Не работает как нужно, всегда предлагает выбрать контейнер, если я до этого сайт открывал в разных контейнерах
- 評價 5 分，滿分 5 分來自 Matthew K.，2 年前
- 評價 5 分，滿分 5 分來自 TruthSeeker，2 年前Add an options page to disable certain functionality. Personally I would only use it to open links from external programs in the focused container. Anyways I appreciate your work!
- 評價 5 分，滿分 5 分來自 Firefox 使用者 13790591，2 年前I'm using Firefox version 116, I've installed this add-on this afternoon, and it has been working perfectly for the last hours.
I see no sign of the problems I've read in older reviews. - 評價 4 分，滿分 5 分來自 Jofish Kaye，3 年前It's a little confusing on first install. It looks like it's not working, because when you open a new tab it doesn't show that it's in the container. But as soon as you start using the tab it'll be in the tab you came from.
- 評價 3 分，滿分 5 分來自 Kayra The Nomad，3 年前It works, but if you try clicking a link on a facebook related page with facebook containers on, it bugs.
- First I was happy, since it seemed to does exactly what was advertised.
Opening a completely new Tab first looks, like its the default container, but switches correctly after entering a search.
Then problems occurred too often to be ignored.
Sometimes it clashes with tabs, that want to be in a concrete container and keeps reopening them to infinity.
Sometimes opening a new tab in a different container results in the extension switching that container back to the last one, even if I wanted that new container.
All in all I am happier with the Simple Tab Groups extension, where I also get my new Tabs correctly contained, while being in the correct group. (Since that extension comes with a lot more functionality, it couldn't be everyone's cup of tea) - 評價 1 分，滿分 5 分來自 Janne Kujanpää，4 年前Too many bugs. Makes new page and new tabs not to open in some use cases.
The idea is excellent but implementation is just too buggy. - 評價 3 分，滿分 5 分來自 Doğan Çelik，5 年前Interesting idea but it's buggy right now. It opens double tabs when used with "Auto Tab Discard" add-on.
- I really liked this until I realized that this was causing my firefox new windows to close the second they open. I believe the problem comes from the extension being unable to decide which container to open a new tab in a new window in, so that needs to be changed. I would love to rate it higher, but this is a really bad bug
- 評價 1 分，滿分 5 分來自 LincolnMorais，5 年前
- 評價 3 分，滿分 5 分來自 Nick Istre，6 年前Does exactly what I wanted when opening new tabs, though it does it after you put in an address in the default container.
Unfortunately, it doesn't allow me to easily open a new window; when you attempt to open a new window from a container tab (Alt/Command-N or File->New Window), the new window immediately closes. You can still open a new window via opening a new tab and dragging it off of the original window, but this is very inconvenient in an multi-workspace environment like KDE, where I often simply want to open a new Firefox window in the current workspace. Moving to the original workspace, dragging a tab out to make a new window, then bringing the window to the workspace I want it is really annoying to do when I simply just want a new Firefox window now.
For my use, this issue makes the add-on basically unusable. Hopefully, this issue can be fixed, or this feature can be part of the base Containers system. - 評價 3 分，滿分 5 分來自 piecevcake，6 年前A good interim workaround for bulk tab imports until they get open in set container/open in original properly sorted.
It reopens the tab when the tab is clicked, in the container that was active before the tab was imported.
Drawbacks: Not working properly with tree tabs.
The tab order is changed, tabs are re-ordered into the order they are activated, and tree structure is lost. (This happens using tree tabs addon, may be caused by it??? - Might this be because the old tab is closed before the new tab is opened?)
Brilliant for bookmarks, onetab etc until open in origina container gets sorted. - 評價 4 分，滿分 5 分來自 Firefox 使用者 14774199，6 年前Works like a charm - needs to be part of the default container implementation.
Only gripe is that the address bar is not in focus on CTRL+T requiring one to reach out for the touchpad/mouse(or double tab again) on opening a new tab to get the focus back on the address bar. - 評價 5 分，滿分 5 分來自 Firefox 使用者 14629945，7 年前
- 評價 5 分，滿分 5 分來自 Firefox 使用者 14110686，7 年前A must-have when you use containers. When using Ctrl+T, it might looks like the new tab is in the default container, but at the moment you enter an URL, it opens it in the correct container. I've been looking for this a long time - I tried a lot of unsatisfying "hacks" - but this extension perfectly does the job.