Bewertungen für KeePassXC-Browser
KeePassXC-Browser von KeePassXC Team
Bewertungen von ha3flt
Bewertet mit 3 von 5 Sternen
von ha3flt, vor 4 JahrenIt would be fair to mention everywhere the well-known problem with snaps on Ubuntu that dramatically cripples the usability of this otherwise great software. Ubuntu is just the largest Linux distribution by far, and you've lost it...
As I said some years ago, you need an alternative way of communication. Shouldn't be so hard, Mozilla Docs says you can use sockets to communicate with local applications (by Native messaging). It's presumably just plain TCP/IP. Even password managers are mentioned as examples...
Time has come - already in 2021 but I postponed the upgrade so far -, and there is no apt-based version of FireFox as a second choice anymore in Ubuntu, only the Snap Store-based, so we are doomed. I will not go backward installing a browser from a place out of the Ubuntu's own ecosystem. Thank you.
---
My response to your response:
Thank you, but an alternative means an alternative. If not the Native Messaging then an encrypted file or similar would have been developed as a way of communication. We talk about years... No way that a FireFox extension can't and couldn't communicate with the outer world.
But as I'm reading here, see the link below that is really easy to find, no doubt, the problem not handling the Native Messaging correctly is in the browsers themselves, and it is already _solved_ after some years in FireFox (in 105..108 betas so far), KeePassXC is working (!) in the tests, I'm about to try it soon. So you are also not informed well enough for some reason...
https://forum.snapcraft.io/t/call-for-testing-native-messaging-support-in-the-firefox-snap/31055/36
It is only in the Beta channel until the next version of FireFox, probably since it is a fresh development from this summer, but it is OK to me because there is a snap of every FireFox beta as well in Ubuntu, and I can install it in parallel to the non-beta version for now if I want.
As I told you, Ubuntu decided sometimes earlier to go with only the snap version of browsers and even if I'm not hundred percent sure it is the best way to go forward, I will not install the less safe and unsupported apt version of browsers again.
As I said some years ago, you need an alternative way of communication. Shouldn't be so hard, Mozilla Docs says you can use sockets to communicate with local applications (by Native messaging). It's presumably just plain TCP/IP. Even password managers are mentioned as examples...
Time has come - already in 2021 but I postponed the upgrade so far -, and there is no apt-based version of FireFox as a second choice anymore in Ubuntu, only the Snap Store-based, so we are doomed. I will not go backward installing a browser from a place out of the Ubuntu's own ecosystem. Thank you.
---
My response to your response:
Thank you, but an alternative means an alternative. If not the Native Messaging then an encrypted file or similar would have been developed as a way of communication. We talk about years... No way that a FireFox extension can't and couldn't communicate with the outer world.
But as I'm reading here, see the link below that is really easy to find, no doubt, the problem not handling the Native Messaging correctly is in the browsers themselves, and it is already _solved_ after some years in FireFox (in 105..108 betas so far), KeePassXC is working (!) in the tests, I'm about to try it soon. So you are also not informed well enough for some reason...
https://forum.snapcraft.io/t/call-for-testing-native-messaging-support-in-the-firefox-snap/31055/36
It is only in the Beta channel until the next version of FireFox, probably since it is a fresh development from this summer, but it is OK to me because there is a snap of every FireFox beta as well in Ubuntu, and I can install it in parallel to the non-beta version for now if I want.
As I told you, Ubuntu decided sometimes earlier to go with only the snap version of browsers and even if I'm not hundred percent sure it is the best way to go forward, I will not install the less safe and unsupported apt version of browsers again.
Antwort des Entwicklers
geschrieben am vor 4 JahrenThe problem here is with Ubuntu Snaps, not with our extension. And the problem is.. with the Native Messaging support. Other extensions are affected too. At this point Ubuntu 22.10 should already support our extension with Firefox as Snap. You can find the info easily. It's also possible to install apt version of Firefox.
We have been using Native Messaging with the extension since the development started in 2016-2017.
We have been using Native Messaging with the extension since the development started in 2016-2017.
753 Bewertungen
- Bewertet mit 3 von 5 Sternenvon sonofevil, vor einem Tag"Error! Credentials cannot be saved or updated to a closed database."
Then open it. Prompt me for the database password. Why can the DB be opened on demand to retrieve passwords, but not to save them? I should not be expected to keep my database open all the time. That is an obvious security vulnerability. So I have it configured to close after 30 seconds. I do not understand why this Addon is so hostile to on-demand database access.Antwort des Entwicklers
geschrieben am vor einem TagAlready requested: https://github.com/keepassxreboot/keepassxc-browser/issues/1541 - Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon Firefox-Benutzer 19944620, vor 5 Tagen
- Bewertet mit 1 von 5 Sternenvon Firefox-Benutzer 13120063, vor 19 TagenWill not work with current version of Firefox and Ubuntu 25.04. I have used this for years. Sad to see Mozilla can not keep up.
Antwort des Entwicklers
geschrieben am vor 15 TagenJust ditch the Snap version of Firefox and everything works. - Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon Firefox-Benutzer 13527928, vor 24 Tagen
- Bewertet mit 2 von 5 Sternenvon chasearoon, vor einem Monat
- Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon evtldocha, vor einem MonatThanks for this extension!
One remark: though firefox now honors XDG config settings in $HOME/.config/mozilla/firefox (on Linux) the extension creates a $HOME/.mozilla/native-messaging-hosts. I'd like so see all config for an application on one single place only. - Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon Firefox-Benutzer 12539057, vor einem Monat
- Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon pocoloco, vor einem MonatGreat plugin for my favorite password safe.
- Bewertet mit 4 von 5 Sternenvon RD, vor einem MonatThe add-on doesn't work in the Flatpak browser. Otherwise, I like KeePassXC :)
Antwort des Entwicklers
geschrieben am vor einem MonatActually there's already pull requests made for a websocket connection mode in both extension and KeePassXC. It works with Flatpak browsers. So it's coming :) - Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon Matthieu, vor 2 Monaten
- Bewertet mit 1 von 5 Sternenvon Abdiel, vor 2 MonatenIt only has offline support. On Linux the configuration is a mess. Sometimes It doesn't talk with my desktop app. Remote support should also be added, so 1 star. I also noticed this while using it: not everything is handled within the browser. When the master password is requested, It switches to the KeepassXC desktop window which makes the experience less convenient. MasterPassword could instead be entered through a small pop-up inside the browser. This is what I would have preferred.
Antwort des Entwicklers
geschrieben am vor 2 MonatenThe whole idea of the extension is that it talks to the desktop app. It has no direct connection to your database, and it will never ask your master password. - Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon toorootoot, vor 2 Monaten
- Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon Mark Andrew Gerads, vor 2 Monaten
- Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon SilverAmd, vor 2 Monaten
- Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon Firefox-Benutzer 19902880, vor 2 Monaten
- Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon Craig, vor 2 Monaten
- Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon Firefox-Benutzer 19882925, vor 3 Monaten
- Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon goqqtw, vor 3 Monaten
- Bewertet mit 1 von 5 Sternenvon Firefox-Benutzer 14868755, vor 3 MonatenNot able to add connected database. Nothing happens when clicking the Connect Database button. Bazzite 43 (linux) NVIDIA edition, Firefox 149, KeePassXC 2.7.12
- Bewertet mit 4 von 5 Sternenvon Saturnus, vor 3 Monaten
- Bewertet mit 4 von 5 Sternenvon Fokeu, vor 4 Monaten
- Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon Firefox-Benutzer 13156335, vor 4 MonatenWorks fine on my Windows 10 Firefox, and in Firefox on my CachyOS Linux install.
- Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon Cangrejo, vor 5 MonatenBest password manager ever.
I know this depends of Keepassxc development, but it would be nice if card info can be stored. - Bewertet mit 5 von 5 Sternenvon elsenfox, vor 5 Monaten
- Bewertet mit 2 von 5 Sternenvon Firefox-Benutzer 19733088, vor 5 MonatenEigentlich gut, aber umständlich, funktioniert bei vielen Websites einfach mal gar nicht, das Felderkennungs-Tool zum Zuweisen ebenfalls nicht und kostet daher viel Zeit und Nerven in der Benutzung. Daher kann ich ebenso schnell und gut aus KeepassXC kopieren und einfügen und brauche mich nicht mit diesem AddOn herumschlagen; leider!