keeps proposing me 4 character "passwords" and does not let me set different preferences for newly generated passwords, nor does it remember the settings used the last time. so i ALWAYS have to manually increase the size, chose words instead of fully random

I use it because of privacy, but that "1" other pass manager has much better app, much MUCH better app and addon.

+
always reliably present
easy to fill form fields
easy to save new access information
-
only the top level domain is saved, not the whole URL, which disqualifies this add-on for webdesigners & co who need to distinguish between back-end, front-end, update panel, database etc

Moved to ProtonPass from 1Password as I was already paying for the Proton suite. Overall, behaves decently. There's a few features I miss from 1Password, such as QR code scanning for OTP, and automatically recognizing a website's password requirements (although I prefer Proton's long text slugs, not all websites will accept them), and linking identities together, e.g. OAuth logins, or linking certain accounts to my entries for my YubiKeys. The integration with PassMail is *chef's kiss* though.

Truly incredible. I like password managing, this is my only password manager. I like it.