'Improve YouTube!' đ§ (For YouTube & Video) Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©sei
'Improve YouTube!' đ§ (For YouTube & Video) szerzĆ: code-for-charity, ImprovedTube
67 értékelés
FejlesztĆi vĂĄlasz
közzétéve: 18 óråjano, please read below.
"Reviews tend to display herd behavior, while to product is complex and hard to judge. The amount of daily uninstalls is low. This project is updated by many volunteers. There might be a mystery bug only affecting 0.1% of users or 1% of Firefox version users - worth discovering, but depending on you filing a bug report."- This extension is pretty buggy and has some bizarre delays. "Force Theater Mode" takes 1 second to activate, I sometimes start moving my mouse to the theater button and then it suddenly activates it. Could've done it myself if it takes this long. Same thing happens with "Shorts: Force to use the standard player", it plays the video for 5 seconds and then reloads the page to the standard player, starting the video from 0:00 again. "Pause while I watch a 2nd video" only works sometimes. Most of the time I have to switch tabs and pause myself. Tried this extension out because it's at the top right now but I got annoyed enough to uninstall and rate it. And no mr. developer, I will not file bug reports for this.
- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: DisplayName, 4 napjaAdd on makes youtube unusably laggy.
And yes developer this is what reviews are for. They're for leaving information for others about the experience of using the app. "Makes the website it's for unusably slow" is useful information for other users. This isn't a technical or bug support request. It's a review of the functionality of the app.FejlesztĆi vĂĄlasz
közzétéve: 2 napjaReviews tend to display herd behavior, while to product is complex and hard to judge.
The amount of daily uninstalls is low. This project is updated by many volunteers.
There might be a mystery bug only affecting 0.1% of users or 1% of Firefox version users - worth discovering, but depending on you filing a bug report.
I meant Mozilla has rules generally allowing to flag / remove this. - Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: Firefox felhasznĂĄlĂł 16192357, 7 napjaToo bad, the options are very relevant, but this extension makes YT unusable: depending on the chosen options, the YT window freezes. Calculation, settings, or others, we don't know what's happening. I don't quite understand the number of positive reviews, as I don't have such an exotic setup (FF 146.0.1 + YT Anti-Translate + Privacy Badger + Ublock Origin + Emoji CheatSet on W11x64).
FejlesztĆi vĂĄlasz
közzétéve: 5 napjano. (reviews are not for this). If there is aynthing, please join the bug report discussion/s https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues?q=state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22z%20FireFox%22
thanks FejlesztĆi vĂĄlasz
közzétéve: 5 napjano. (reviews are not for this). If there is aynthing, please join the bug report discussion/s https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues?q=state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22z%20FireFox%22
thanks- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: Firefox felhasznĂĄlĂł 13581270, 20 napja
FejlesztĆi vĂĄlasz
közzétéve: 5 napjano. (reviews are not for this). If there is aynthing, please join the bug report discussion/s https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues?q=state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22z%20FireFox%22
thanks- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: Firefox felhasznĂĄlĂł 16768472, egy hĂłnapjaThe performance is very bad and the developer doesn't seem to be willing to fix it. Furthermore some features are missing and the ones that do exist don't work reliable, probably because of the very bad performance.
FejlesztĆi vĂĄlasz
közzétéve: 5 napjano. (reviews are not for this). If there is aynthing, please join the bug report discussion/s https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues?q=state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22z%20FireFox%22
thanks - Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: Firefox felhasznĂĄlĂł 18986140, 2 hĂłnapjaThis extension doesnât perform as advertised! Iâm not sure what people like about it or why it receives high reviews, but it fails to fulfill the primary purpose for which I downloaded it. I wanted it to remove âShortsâ from my search results and home page. While it does partially remove them from my home page, it does nothing to improve my search results. Regardless of which toggles I activate, every search is completely filled with âShorts,â rendering this extension useless for my needs.
- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: Betablockr, 2 hĂłnapjaIt simply doesn't work for the mobile YouTube site, only the desktop site which is unfortunate
- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: john, 2 hĂłnapjavery high cpu usage now. wasnt a problem until a few days ago.
FejlesztĆi vĂĄlasz
közzétéve: 5 napjano. (reviews are not for this). If there is aynthing, please join the bug report discussion/s https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues?q=state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22z%20FireFox%22
thanks - Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: LL K, 2 hĂłnapjaThe extension offers a lot of useful features, but it severely affected my Firefox performance immediately after installation. The browser became noticeably slower, and C.P.U. usage spiked by ~35%. From what Iâve seen in other reviews, the developer tends to dismiss, and deny these performance issues rather than investigating, or assisting affected users; replying with responses in denial, instead of looking into the issue. Unfortunately, due to these problems and the lack of constructive support, I cannot recommend this extension.
- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: keenoy, 2 hĂłnapjaIt's works fine on PC but not on mobile. Blacklist does not work at all and even freezes the browser.
- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: SzymonL, 4 hĂłnapja
- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: DOT, 5 hĂłnapja
- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: Firefox felhasznĂĄlĂł 19242234, 5 hĂłnapjaThis addon claims there are filter rules. There are no filter rules that I could see. Searching the menu for "filter" reveals nothing. At best, you can "block" channels and videos, a feature youtube already has.
Also, installing this caused all of my firefox tabs on youtube to stop responding, forcing me to close and reopen each.
It's weird to me how strongly they are marketing this addon, too, and the uninstall page vaguely tries to guilt trip you for removing the plugin. I realize this is recommended by mozilla, but it's tripping a lot of sus metrics for me, and I can't recommend it.
Edit: Further review of the developer's responses on low scoring reviews make me even more certain this isn't a good idea. 1) The developers respond to claims the plugin slows users' browser down with "nuh uh no it doesn't" and "yeah well why don't you measure the milliseconds with dev tools?", and 2) The devs claim that voting less than 5 stars is "voting against the project". Why does that matter? Why does your score on your open source, free project matter? It's almost like you're pushing for popularity on your plugin for some other reason. It's incredibly suspicious, and that type of language is couched in incredibly manipulative undertones. *Don't install this.* This thing is full of red flags.FejlesztĆi vĂĄlasz
közzĂ©tĂ©ve: 4 hĂłnapjaHi, the word filter applies to our many layout and display:none features. However content-filtering can be the biggest roadmap item since we have not implemented or been asked, most of it. You can read up on it here https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues?q=is%3Aissue%20state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22Filtering%20%26%20Discovery%20(of%20Content)%22 )(half of which remains monologues with no user participation) https://github.com/MarcGuiselin/youtube-refined did some, yet only found about 1000 users then. Recently our new "competitor" Untrap has some too i think and is surprisingly the most / only likely developer to be reading our repo and roadmap. (If you can, suggest them not to collab / not reinvent this difficult task https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/discussions/1881). You can give fair feedback and you might not want to frustrate volunteers. We could also flag this ("Misplaced bug report or support request"), but prefer to keep information visible. There is no marketing budget and usually that would leave traces. When driven by suspicion, you might have more fun /success examining code. (You could enhance global security scanners or run your own). - Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: Beeg, 6 hĂłnapjacool addon but how do I block certain channel? I don't see any button to do that.
- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: Thraug, 7 hĂłnapjaCan't make it block shorts or playables, which is all I want the extension to do. I have every option enabled to block shorts and they still appear on YouTube mobile in my browser. What am I doing wrong?
- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: Firefox felhasznĂĄlĂł 12474497, 7 hĂłnapja
- Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: Foxy_Chipher, 8 hĂłnapja
FejlesztĆi vĂĄlasz
közzétéve: 8 hónapjaIt works on www.youtube.com! (And we can add m.youtube.com anytime)- Very slow (even by youtube standards), whatever what the dev will say: sometimes takes almost a minute to load a youtube video, and often will fail to load the full page, with the comments.
Very buggy: again, often failing to load a page fully, the mini-player suddenly not appearing anymore when scrolling down, or among many others, the limiting to H.264 not working reliably (to be fair, it only reliably works with enhanced-h264ify, whichever main youtube extension I use). Even the menu is buggy: the search bar will always cover the link to go back in the menu (so one has to close that search bar again and again), and if used in the extension panel (as opposed to using it pinned), it won't even fit the window properly, lol!
Fortunately, I discovered a little used extension (Tweaks for youtube: only about 3k users, which is baffling), that is great where Improve youtube isn't at all. I tested them all, and that's the only one I'll keep. - Csillagos Ă©rtĂ©kelĂ©s: 1 / 5kĂ©szĂtette: Firefox felhasznĂĄlĂł 18744881, egy Ă©vewas working for a period of time but in the last month any settings used would lag youtube; back button and pause taking forever.
removed extension and youtube stared working again, unfortunate as it was a good addition :/FejlesztĆi vĂĄlasz
közzétéve: egy évehi! :) please don't rate us wrongfully but mind this doesn't start or end with your usage. This is a hardworking volunteer initiative since 12 years, with 150 contributors on github, and inspite we modestly have to race uphill all them time during Youtube changes.
Please don't buy or spread baseless rumors about lags. (Every software will take some time (lke 0.001 second). We changed nothing mad a minor visual update 10 days ago, none in November