Perfect !

Doesn't log me into the extension, also can only forward emails to my gmail and not protonmail...

The absurdly high 5-to-1 star review ratio is very well earned.

Very reliable. They continue to support all the aliases you set up on a paid plan even after the plan ends! You just won't be able to make new aliases if you already have more than the free plan's limit. But this policy alone puts so many other aliasing services to shame, and it makes me want to give them more money.

It's absolutely painless to point it at a different email address if you switch email providers, too.

First of all, it's opensource, it works, and all features are stable as the Stonehenge. My recommendation to everyone, who cares about privacy. I also pay for yearly subscription

Once you start using it, it becomes so natural that it just feels weird do give your true mail to any service at all.

Easy, secure and awesome

SimpleLogin is good, but the extension is pretty basic and bad UX.

Clicking the button makes an alias, but most webforms don't register the input so as soon as you click into the field it disapears. The extension doesn't bother to copy it to your clipboard, so most times you have to manually type it back in, or go to the SimpleLogin dashboard to re-copy it, which sort of defeats the point.

The simplelogin service is great! The extension could use a bunch of UX improvements; mostly in speed. It's just ... slow; and tiny; and very, very pink.