KeePassXC-Browser incelemeleri
KeePassXC-Browser geliştiren: KeePassXC Team
Gongloss adlı kullanıcının incelemesi
5 üzerinden 3 puan
yazan: Gongloss, 2 yıl önceBasically broken, like, apparently, all third-party password extensions.
Often doesn't find passwords for sites. Tells you every single time that you've updated the password and asks if you want to resave it, so you have no way to tell if the password has actually changed. It always says it has, whether it has or it hasn't.
Can't find TOTP codes even when they're in Keepass, you have to go copy them by hand.
All-around seems like a half-finished, "beta" release that is almost ready for use, but not quite.
It is extremely nerve-wracking to constantly be told the password has changed, and have to stop and think about whether it has and whether you want to save it, every single time you log into a site. Worse, you can only see this before you have logged in, before you know if the login was any good... it disappears as soon as you're in.
So, basically, it keeps you on your toes, always keeps you guessing and uncertain about what's going on... exactly what you DON'T EVER WANT A PASSWORD MANAGER TO DO.
Extremely disappointing.
EDIT: Response to the developer's comment below: The user guide, which is one mammoth long page from a page 2 or 3 levels deep on the website, contains one instance each of the phrases "new password" and "banner", neither telling me anything about how to fix this. I searched for the word "changed" too, that doesn't appear anywhere in the document at all.
Also, when you do need to use that banner, the buttons don't do anything. Click them, they sit there. Did they work? Did they not? Did anything get saved? No way to know.
I truly hate to criticize a FOSS project but this is really just awful design, to the point I don't trust this thing. If I don't know when passwords are new or not, or whether it's saving them or not, and I have to scour a huge 12,000 word single-page wall of text that doesn't turn up the information I need even when I search it for the specific terms the developer told the manual would instruct me on, so I can't find the new password banner settings by searching for "new password" or "banner" then, sorry, I have to nope out on it. I'm just not reading a 12,000 word manual to figure out how to use a password manager.
Just for fun, I printed the gargantuan "manual" page to a PDF. It's a single page that's 49 pages long when printed. That's what I'm expected to have read just to figure out how to get a password manager to work. That's not a user manual, it's a novella.
I scrolled slowly through the eldritch document's 78 different screenshots to see if there was one of the banner in question, to maybe tip me off where its behavior is documented. If there is one, I could not find it.
I did find the section on the browser integration plugin and read it through carefully, twice. It says nothing about that banner, or how to understand it, or get it to work in a way that seems to make sense. I'll limp along with copying and pasting codes from KeepassXC for TOTP since there's no way I'm going back to Authy or using Google Auth, but for passwords, I've had to go back to the limitations of just using Firefox's built-in password manager. I'd hoped for a better solution than that, but... :-\
Often doesn't find passwords for sites. Tells you every single time that you've updated the password and asks if you want to resave it, so you have no way to tell if the password has actually changed. It always says it has, whether it has or it hasn't.
Can't find TOTP codes even when they're in Keepass, you have to go copy them by hand.
All-around seems like a half-finished, "beta" release that is almost ready for use, but not quite.
It is extremely nerve-wracking to constantly be told the password has changed, and have to stop and think about whether it has and whether you want to save it, every single time you log into a site. Worse, you can only see this before you have logged in, before you know if the login was any good... it disappears as soon as you're in.
So, basically, it keeps you on your toes, always keeps you guessing and uncertain about what's going on... exactly what you DON'T EVER WANT A PASSWORD MANAGER TO DO.
Extremely disappointing.
EDIT: Response to the developer's comment below: The user guide, which is one mammoth long page from a page 2 or 3 levels deep on the website, contains one instance each of the phrases "new password" and "banner", neither telling me anything about how to fix this. I searched for the word "changed" too, that doesn't appear anywhere in the document at all.
Also, when you do need to use that banner, the buttons don't do anything. Click them, they sit there. Did they work? Did they not? Did anything get saved? No way to know.
I truly hate to criticize a FOSS project but this is really just awful design, to the point I don't trust this thing. If I don't know when passwords are new or not, or whether it's saving them or not, and I have to scour a huge 12,000 word single-page wall of text that doesn't turn up the information I need even when I search it for the specific terms the developer told the manual would instruct me on, so I can't find the new password banner settings by searching for "new password" or "banner" then, sorry, I have to nope out on it. I'm just not reading a 12,000 word manual to figure out how to use a password manager.
Just for fun, I printed the gargantuan "manual" page to a PDF. It's a single page that's 49 pages long when printed. That's what I'm expected to have read just to figure out how to get a password manager to work. That's not a user manual, it's a novella.
I scrolled slowly through the eldritch document's 78 different screenshots to see if there was one of the banner in question, to maybe tip me off where its behavior is documented. If there is one, I could not find it.
I did find the section on the browser integration plugin and read it through carefully, twice. It says nothing about that banner, or how to understand it, or get it to work in a way that seems to make sense. I'll limp along with copying and pasting codes from KeepassXC for TOTP since there's no way I'm going back to Authy or using Google Auth, but for passwords, I've had to go back to the limitations of just using Firefox's built-in password manager. I'd hoped for a better solution than that, but... :-\
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 2 yıl önceIf a password is always offered to a site, or it doesn't find your passwords, your entry URL is probably incorrect. Use the simplest possible form of the URL, for example https://example.com.
Users can modify the settings how the new password created banner is displayed. Reading the User Guide is highly recommended.
Users can modify the settings how the new password created banner is displayed. Reading the User Guide is highly recommended.
761 inceleme
- 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: elia, 6 saat önce
- 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: TitoVodis, bir gün önce
- 5 üzerinden 1 puanyazan: Frank, 7 gün önceUseless. No connection to the database. KeePass 2 only needs a key/pair setup, but KeePassXC requires hours of troubleshooting and tons of tutorials just to get it working. I went back to KeePass 2.
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 5 gün önceThat is what this extension also does. If something does not work directly, it's usually something with your system. And that is why the troubleshooting guide exists. - 5 üzerinden 1 puanyazan: Firefox kullanıcısı 12580101, 7 gün önceI couldn't get it to work. I wasted a lot of time in trying. I have a lot of experience with programming and windows. I've used keepass since 1.0 or earlier and was trying to move off 2.0 because it cannot identify window titles in win11 wild cards or not and has quirks on opning from the toolbar. But neither can this. In fact it shows the same operational failures as 2.0. I did not test toolbar with xc. Obviously some have gotten it to work but it appears the list of those that cannot get it to work is growing. Back to 2.0 for me. There is no way in this world the average user can use this extension or xc.
- 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: dev421, 17 gün önceSupports everything you'd expect - TOTP, passkeys, auto-saving credentials, SSH agent. The Free Man's Choice since 2012
- 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: hinoki, bir ay önce
- 5 üzerinden 1 puanyazan: Richard, bir ay önceI really love Keepass and have used it for years. I really wish that there was a way to link/connect it to a web browser. So far I have not found any working method to get passwords out of keepass other than copy/pasting from the program apart from on an iPhone.
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: bir ay önceThere are two ways you can get credentials out from KeePassXC: using the browser extension, or using Auto-Type. Please refer to our documention for guides: https://keepassxc.org/docs/ - 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: Blood-Art, bir ay önce
- "Error! Credentials cannot be saved or updated to a closed database."
Then open it. Prompt me for the database password. Why can the DB be opened on demand to retrieve passwords, but not to save them? I should not be expected to keep my database open all the time. That is an obvious security vulnerability. So I have it configured to close after 30 seconds. I do not understand why this Addon is so hostile to on-demand database access.Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 2 ay önceAlready requested: https://github.com/keepassxreboot/keepassxc-browser/issues/1541 - 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: Firefox kullanıcısı 19944620, 2 ay önce
- 5 üzerinden 1 puanyazan: Firefox kullanıcısı 13120063, 2 ay önceWill not work with current version of Firefox and Ubuntu 25.04. I have used this for years. Sad to see Mozilla can not keep up.
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 2 ay önceJust ditch the Snap version of Firefox and everything works. - 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: Firefox kullanıcısı 13527928, 2 ay önce
- 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: chasearoon, 3 ay önce
- Thanks for this extension!
One remark: though firefox now honors XDG config settings in $HOME/.config/mozilla/firefox (on Linux) the extension creates a $HOME/.mozilla/native-messaging-hosts. I'd like so see all config for an application on one single place only. - 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: Firefox kullanıcısı 12539057, 3 ay önce
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 3 ay önceActually there's already pull requests made for a websocket connection mode in both extension and KeePassXC. It works with Flatpak browsers. So it's coming :)- It only has offline support. On Linux the configuration is a mess. Sometimes It doesn't talk with my desktop app. Remote support should also be added, so 1 star. I also noticed this while using it: not everything is handled within the browser. When the master password is requested, It switches to the KeepassXC desktop window which makes the experience less convenient. MasterPassword could instead be entered through a small pop-up inside the browser. This is what I would have preferred.
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 3 ay önceThe whole idea of the extension is that it talks to the desktop app. It has no direct connection to your database, and it will never ask your master password. - 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: toorootoot, 3 ay önce
- 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: Mark Andrew Gerads, 4 ay önce
- 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: Firefox kullanıcısı 19902880, 4 ay önce
- 5 üzerinden 5 puanyazan: Firefox kullanıcısı 19882925, 4 ay önce