Improve YouTube! (Open-Source for YouTube) incelemeleri
Improve YouTube! (Open-Source for YouTube) geliştiren: code-for-charity, ImprovedTube
36 inceleme
- 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: michael, 17 saat önceI like idea... But it's only caused trouble. I downloaded for youtube video looping but when listening to videos in a playlist w/ looping, it keeps appending buttons for some reason. So my screen is full of buttons. In addition, looping sometimes doesn't work and it skips to next playlist video.
- 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: Riku70X, 22 gün önceI just want a button to reverse a playlist. It's great when it works, but most of the time it just does not show up even though it's absolutely checked in the settings (other stuff works fine, I can change the themes easily, but the entire playlist section just does nothing)
- 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: tiny dragon, bir ay önceI want to like this extension so badly. It seems so promising. It's free and made by volunteers and open source.
But I've been trying it off and on for months now, and during that time I've tried it on 4 different browsers and 3 different operating systems (two desktop, one mobile), and it's always broken in multiple ways, and it always absolutely murders Firefox's performance.
Yes, I tried disabling other youtube and adblock extensions. And I tried running Improve Youtube alone and in private mode, with no other extensions. No dice.
And no, my computer is not a potato (nor is my phone). And this is the only addon that's been causing me problems like this.
This extension is just extremely broken, all the time, always. It feels like a super early alpha release, not a finished addon.
You can report issues on github, but even *if* that leads to the issue getting fixed in a halfway timely manner, there are always additional issues occuring at the same time.
There's no predicting which options in the settings menu will work, or which will break even more things, and seemingly aaaaaaall of them tank the browser's performance.
I genuinely don't understand how this addon is getting good reviews. I can imagine it might become an incredible addon eventually, if the tsunami of problems is ever overcome, and I really hope it does, but for right now... Don't waste your time, like I did. There are alternatives to this addon that actually work, and reliably so.
I'd only recommend installing this addon if you're wanting to get involved in developing it, by way of a hobby project. - 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: Firefox kullanıcısı 19465923, 3 ay önceThemes and some settings are ok. I just do not like that whenever I switch from a tab to youtube and vice versa, there is a short amount of time where the page reloads. I have no idea why it keeps doing this. It also has issues wherein despite not enabling the "Force videos to start from the beginning", it still forces videos to start from the beginning. It's annoying and worth the uninstall. Hopefully they fix such issues by then
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 5 ay önceno (how many milliseconds would it have to take for you to be able to notice? and why not document & measure it with F12)Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 6 ay öncethe feature just received an update. (please differ outdated feature vs actual freezing/ or cpu load) . You shouldn't be surprised when one in 200 features ever needs an update, but be surprised how our development team of 0 people keeps up with Youtube's changed like Sisyphus most of the time. (There might be guarantees for fast updated in future, if we get any funding.)- 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: Devin Rozsas, 9 ay önceThe main reason I wanted this extension was to make Youtube stop spamming already watched videos, random playlists and useless shorts.
1) It doesn't block already watched videos, it just makes them less visible by hiding the thumbnail and dimming their links;
2) Sometimes it marks random videos as watched, but I never even clicked their links, even less watched them;
3) It cannot block playlists, as far as I used it;
4) It blocks shorts successfully AND entirely (not just dim their links).Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 6 ay öncePlease join us on github. (Firefox Addon Reviews are not intended for bug reports BTW.)
Thank you! :) - 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: Firefox kullanıcısı 18820010, 10 ay önce
- 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: Gemini62167, bir yıl önceA fairly decent extension for YT except that it is losing some of the most desirable functions for some reason. The skip ad feature doesn't work at all no matter what option you choose.
I wouldn't mind the ads so much and let many of them play except for the fact that most of them are so ridiculous, it's like a video example of the kind of ads you find in the National Enquirer. They're utterly unbelievable (or should be), but for whatever reason it appears the same kind of marketing and advertising laws and regulations just don't seem to apply on the internet. You can claim just about anything or misrepresent, twist and bend truth with fact to confuse people into believing things with abandon. Its the same kind of tactics the consrevativce media has been using increasingly since the 1980s. It's been going on for two generations now and trying to point this out, prove fallacy with fact is impossible. And for this, I don't think I nor anyone else should be required to watch this nonsense, I don't care if it's how these videos are monetized or not. Lying and manipulation for the sake of selling product is not an excusable reason. Sorry, I'm one of the few that still believes in ethics in this society. And really, as far as YT is concerned, it wouldn't exist at all if people didn't upload videos to begin with, so I'm not one to fall on my knees in tears over the plight of YT not making enough money to keep its investors happy. They could all go f**k themselves.
To continue...
As for the functions of this extension that seemed to have ceased to work, the mixer section does not register any open tabs and thus does not work. And, should you reload your page you will have to hit the extension pinned to your toolbar to get it to begin functioning at all with those options that still work. Sad really. Because for what it is supposed to do, it offers much in a very compact and easy to use design.Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: bir yıl önceHi! :)
> you will have to hit the extension pinned to your toolbar to get it to begin functioning
in the current firefox you have to first allow extensions to run always.
you don't sound like giving this free public service less than 5 stars (what makes one greedy or believing in negative-motivation?)
Ads: the features hides all banners and tries to skip different version of the skip button it is just one in 200 features, not relevant, not unique and we might stop or separate it for legal clarity https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues/2751#issuecomment-2560581960 (read all by @improvedtube)
BTW currently a bug might disables a few more features unnecessarily and unfortunately firefox has not viewed the fix yet since December 29. - 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: Rash, bir yıl önceI am on android Firefox 133.0 with ImproveTube 4.1122
Ad block isn't working
"Shorts" hiding on homepage isn't working - 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: frikdt, bir yıl önceFor an award-winning Firefox-supported extension I find documentation on the provided functionality sorely lacking. I installed this mainly for the blocking feature, hoping to replace the retarded native youtube algorithm. After a frustrating hour or two, unable to figure out how the blocklist is supposed to work, checking the extension documentation, their home (github) page, and even returning to this installation page, I'm giving up.
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: bir yıl öncehi! :) yes! this has been an very special uphill race for 11.5 years - and no time to document enough (but you can can help us.) And blocklist appears in the lastest video review from a popular channel as stated in our wiki. You can enable it and then see a new block button on thumbnails and on channel pages. And more that you might suggest (maybe also a keyboard short cut to block the current channel?) - As a maintainer i care for unique features the most that). (aand luckily the blocklist feature got a whole overhaul / rewrite with these month and we can upload another update for it in a few days. (and you could help test that one already). - 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: Anonymous, 2 yıl önce
- 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: J3ster, 2 yıl öncePros: Minimalist layout, probably does something there's a bunch of settings
Cons: Doesn't fix the garbage new layout which is the only thing I wanted it to doGeliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 2 yıl önceBad/unfair. You should rate us for the many things we do already. (Who said we would predict every YouTube change immediately 24/7/365 and if you want it or don't want it? ~2x impossible) - Yet you can have a look in our list of topics in the bottom of the extension: https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues/2178 (Where you can see how. While you dont need us for this, we might also provide it soon to save you from copy&paste) - 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: octopiliar, 2 yıl önceHas many good assets to youtube however my main problem seems to be the screenshot tab as any edit to the main youtube page takes a screenshot of whatever video I'm watching and I won't even realize until I have fifteen screenshots of the same image on my PC
- 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: metalrice, 2 yıl önceThe thumbnails for blocked channels still show up on the home screen. Most of the thumbnail is blocked out except for the top portion.
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 2 yıl öncehi! please make a bug report on github https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues/new?assignees=&labels=Bug thank you!
(btw reviews are not supposed to be about a bug(, which might only happen to few people or because of a YouTube update.) This is one of the 3 reason here allowing to flag/remove them. To make it harder our project is an uphill race against this since 11 years and work never ends. There are few extensions as ambitious as this and actually it would deserve 10 stars. (If you expect a majority of features to work for you, then you are expecting more work and more reliability already than most 5-star extensions provide to their single purposes. Yet they are what the rating systems will thus prefer. ) We currently might aim at ~95% of the stuff working for you costing most of our free time. And if we ever get funded might finally hire people and develop even several times faster.) - 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: Firefox kullanıcısı 12851851, 2 yıl önce
- 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: Sumon, 3 yıl önce
- 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: Toxic Raven, 3 yıl önceThis addon had some nice features, but probably from a combination of youtube changing too much and the addon getting no updates, there are some wonky functionalities that I don't have the patience to deal with. Too bad, it was a good one for a while
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 3 yıl öncehi! ♥ 4.0.17.1 will be live in Firefox any moment with ~100 improvements. Unfortunately we lost our maintainer in 2022, but are getting back on track. We are over 500000 active users and only 1-3 active developers. Every volunteer will help https://github.com/code-for-charity/ImprovedTube-for-YouTube - 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: migzon, 3 yıl önceNot been updated nearly in a year. Many features not working.
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 3 yıl öncehi! ♥ 4.0.17.1 will be live in Firefox any moment with ~100 improvements. Unfortunately we lost our maintainer in 2022, but are getting back on track. We are over 500000 active users and only 1-3 active developers. Every volunteer will help https://github.com/code-for-charity/ImprovedTube-for-YouTube - 5 üzerinden 2 puanyazan: m76, 3 yıl önceIt doesn't do what I want, while doing a lot of things I don't want that can't be turned off.
Geliştiricinin yanıtı
gönderilme: 3 yıl öncehi! :) does nothing by default! (Only when you enable features.) Update soon.
thanks! consider joining us on github were we are active daily.
hi! ♥ 4.0.17.1 will be live in Firefox any moment with ~100 improvements. Unfortunately we lost our maintainer in 2022, but are getting back on track. We are over 500000 active users and only 1-3 active developers. Every volunteer will help https://github.com/code-for-charity/ImprovedTube-for-YouTube