Đánh giá cho Tridactyl
Tridactyl bởi Colin Caine, Oliver Blanthorn
Đánh giá bởi bool3max
Xếp hạng 4 trong số 5
bởi bool3max, 7 năm trướcEDIT: The more and more and I use it the more bugs I find. e.g. :tabopen opens 3 blank tabs every time it is used. Extremely annoying.
Lots of really annoying quirks that are not limitations of this addon but of the WebExtension API. Thus we can't really factor them in the review.
Some of them include not being able to use any bindings before a page has fully loaded, not being able to use bindings on about:blank, etc...
One major factor that could definitely be improved upon is performance. There's a noticeable delay when switching tabs and especially when typing commands in the console.
Also the link-follow UI with the giant yellow rectangles is atrocious. Lots of duplicate links, poor visibility. Vim Vixen does much better in that regard.
Other than that the addon is really good and I appreciate all the work that's been put into it. Once the WebExtension API improves I don't doubt that we'll see a lot of improvements in Tridactyl too.
Lots of really annoying quirks that are not limitations of this addon but of the WebExtension API. Thus we can't really factor them in the review.
Some of them include not being able to use any bindings before a page has fully loaded, not being able to use bindings on about:blank, etc...
One major factor that could definitely be improved upon is performance. There's a noticeable delay when switching tabs and especially when typing commands in the console.
Also the link-follow UI with the giant yellow rectangles is atrocious. Lots of duplicate links, poor visibility. Vim Vixen does much better in that regard.
Other than that the addon is really good and I appreciate all the work that's been put into it. Once the WebExtension API improves I don't doubt that we'll see a lot of improvements in Tridactyl too.
Phản hồi của nhà phát triển
đã đăng 7 năm trướcThanks for the review. We're aware and working on most of the issues you've mentioned.
> [... T]he link-follow UI with the giant yellow rectangles is atrocious. Lots of duplicate links, poor visibility. Vim Vixen does much better in that regard.
Please could you file an issue detailing the page(s) where you see duplicate links, or they have poor visibility? We've tried quite hard to remove duplicates from hints. Our issues page is here: https://github.com/tridactyl/tridactyl/issues
Thanks!
> [... T]he link-follow UI with the giant yellow rectangles is atrocious. Lots of duplicate links, poor visibility. Vim Vixen does much better in that regard.
Please could you file an issue detailing the page(s) where you see duplicate links, or they have poor visibility? We've tried quite hard to remove duplicates from hints. Our issues page is here: https://github.com/tridactyl/tridactyl/issues
Thanks!
517 đánh giá
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Yorly Quintero, một tháng trước
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi PotatoHuang, một tháng trước
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi skrewt, một tháng trướcI like Tridactyl so far- it's my first foray into browser vim emulation and it does pretty well on most sites. I really appreciate motions like `gi` that let you jump to the main input field on a site.
I've found that it doesn't completely replace mouse navigation for me; several sites I use have nonconventional clickable elements (not buttons/hrefs) and so the `f` finder doesn't highlight them, and `;;` highlights so many things it's hard to find the right one.
I'm still solidly on the learning curve, but it's already made certain actions way quicker for me, and I love the command line- with some quick theming it's probably the coolest thing about my Firefox now!
The native plugin works seamlessly too- and the ability to edit text in my preferred editor (Shoutout to Helix!) has been great as well.
Solid work, highly recommended to give it a shot if you like modal editors. - Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Người dùng Firefox 17112212, một tháng trướcfantastique. tridactyl is the most thought out and perfected exploration of what is imo an important branch of browsers as technology.
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi user-1231241251266543315263456789654321, 2 tháng trướcmakes the web so much more enjoyable!
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi TypicalUser128, 2 tháng trướcIt works on more sites than Vimium. It's faster than Vimium. Tridactyl is simply better than Vimium. Only Qutebrowser is more effective than this. Wow.
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi v69777, 2 tháng trướcI tried several keyboard-oriented browsers, but for now nothing beats Firefox with Tridactyl installed.
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Người dùng Firefox 18524146, 3 tháng trướcI have tried Vimium, Vimium C, Surfing Keys, and a few others; however, Tridactyl is the best. It is comparable in terms of raw power and capability to Qutebrowser, which is remarkable. I have yet to find a use case where a Qutebrowser solution did not also work in Tridactyl. My favorite features include the `:command` mode to execute complex commands (including chaining them), the ability to use custom JavaScript, the tridactylrc file (makes it easy to sync dotfiles), the ability to control other add-ons, and the ability to control Firefox itself (i.e., clear history, local storage, etc: by time or whatever). It is without a doubt the most feature-rich Vim-like browser add-on; as a result, it also loads the slowest. It also currently has issues with Google Docs/Sheets/Drive, so you may need to use an alternative (like Vimium) for those sites. Lastly, this add-on also requires the most learning and configuration to use efficiently, as it is the most complex. In conclusion, if you are a power user who strives to abandon the mouse entirely with full control over the browser, then Tridactyl is the add-on for you. But if you just want something simple, then Vimium or Surfing Keys are always an option too.
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Pawel, 4 tháng trước
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Vovix, 5 tháng trước
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi happsen, 5 tháng trước
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Helkin, 6 tháng trướcGreat user experience.
I just remove default Ctrl-f bind since it is burned into my muscle memory that it’s this to find on a web browser. - Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Flat, dark and simple, 7 tháng trướcAmazing extension, only lacking on the theme documentation
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi aaronedev, 7 tháng trước
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi rev0kable, 7 tháng trướcThis Vim modeled addon has the most features for a power user, it have more of a learning curve than say, Vimium if you want to utilize the additional capabilities.
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Người dùng Firefox 19545892, 7 tháng trướcBrowsing gets faster with this extension however it doesn't enhance firefox to be as good as qutebrowser
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Người dùng Firefox 15962029, 8 tháng trước
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi mi6, 8 tháng trước
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Người dùng Firefox 19438303, 9 tháng trước
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Người dùng Firefox 17908336, 9 tháng trước
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Rockey, 9 tháng trước
- Xếp hạng 5 trong số 5bởi Người dùng Firefox 19201857, 9 tháng trước