Really good addon, does exactly what it is supposed to. there is just one feature that the competitor (wikiwand) has, that modern has not: inverting the colors of images (svgs) with transparent backgrounds. This would be extremely helpful to make stuff like graphs and plots with transparent background and black font for axis descriptions more legible in dark modes. If this was added, id give 5 stars.

What can be improved:
1. How links are shown. Wikiwand does a great job at this with their ability to underline links, without the color being blue.
2. How photos are shown in media viewer. A more modern, minimalism approach is necessary.

Way better than wikiwand

Very well-made extension, does excellent beauty and ux improvements. Deducting a star because the language switcher really misses some kind of "favourite/pinned" language(s), searching for it in a big list each time is annoying. The dark themes aren't quite to my liking either; they are very functional but not pretty (I use slate, it's ok).

The search box option links are broken. They can't be selected.

Some parts are still in white even though I turned on dark mode

Works great on LTR languages, but fonts are bad for RTL, specifically Hebrew, and the setting controls are all reverted and confusing.

Cool but how the hell do I change the settings and theme everyone is talking about.? There are no options in the extension or the wikipedia website.

This brings an enjoyable experience to reading Wikipedia... except the dark theme has some serious problem with blockquotes: background is same white as for text. I think it's a wrong choice of contrast to overall dim theme, and I would love to see it fixed.

Could you please add light grey background, like this one on firefox website.
Well done on making this extension!

Edit: Also adding "most recent languages" or letting us to put one language of our choice at the top of "change language menu", would be helpful.

Does not seem to work on Chinese version.

Unsure if this is a bug with using this on an ultrawide monitor but the size difference between the 3rd and 2nd largest column widths is too drastic - would prefer at least another 2 sizes in between. A "warm" dark mode would be nice as well.

Change font size not working for Chinese.

Great extension, however for Persian (a right to left language) somehow this extension fails to fully work and shows dark theme as light instead.

Suggestion: Make left sidebar actually collapsible so that content can take more space when zooming on smaller screen. I'll keep using the Mobile Wikipedia extension since it allows for a better use of screen estate. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/mobile-wikipedia-webextension/

I appreciate that some will find this an preferable to default Wikipedia, but I found nothing to like about it. It's well implemented, but it wasn't for me. Not even close.

Suggestion: Since everything is bigger (fontsize, left panel, etc) the content should be full page. No need for this right margin now.