This is a fantastic option for those that have amassed a huge amount of bookmarks over the years and just want a simple script to help clear up the broken links or verify what addresses need to be updated. However it doesn't allow me to reorganize where my bookmarks are, which I assumed would be an option with the name of the program. I'll be using this again though as it's still a very good option!

I appreciate the effort to develop the extension but to be honest the interface is ugly and impractical. Regarding results I have found that out of some 3000 links the extension did find some 10% as broken. Testing the "broken" links I have found that most of them rendered the pages just fine.
Extension deleted.

贼好用，清除失效书签，一键重定向

Its pretty useful, but my main issue is that there is no option to remove bookmark duplicates, en masse, leaving behind the first bookmark found, a la bookmark deduplicator. Its a real pain to be hunting down hundreds of possible duplicates one by one. If that feature could be implemented then you found yourself a permanent user!

Seems to work well, but I have some feedback:
1) Details about the error or warning would be great to include in the results. As it is I'm having to right-click each URL and open in a new tab to see what's going on.
2) Would it be possible to add an option users could enable if they so choose to update favicons at the same time?

I have 72000+ bookmarks. Your check always dies before the end. Alas.

1. Well looking for duplicates and problem names + 1 stars. 2. There is no button to stop checking the bookmarks. If you close the tab, then the process continues and helps to unload the browser through the task manager - minus the star. 3. Does not display what errors occurred when connecting, namely 404, 505, etc. - minus the star. 4. There are no settings for the number of requests to the site when checking - minus one star.

Hi,

after a bad XMark sync all my bookmarks were doubled so I wanted to use this addon to remove the 3000 duplicated bookmarks. It also detects them and displays them but I have to click to delete for every single bookmark.


Please, add a button to delete all duplicates at once!

Works for me on the current FF. One question - the 3 little green dots are always active? It makes me wonder if the app is never finished processing if they never stop moving.

As another reviewer was saying, things may work better if the dup check is done first.
If you check broken links first, it may hang.

Very intuitive. But took me a bit to get use to the large split screen. Only problem was I had to disable it to get back to normal window. Perhaps because I'm using an older version of FF (v. 52.0.1 (64 bit) on Win 10.

For some reason, it always recognizes https://transfer.sh/ as error.

The guy who posted the previous review was referring to the forever looping logo animation overlay that prevents you to even delete the 1 duplicate it finds (though you can do it manually via library)
https://github.com/cadeyrn/bookmarks-organizer/issues/48 since Aug 14

Or another one with a screenshot https://github.com/cadeyrn/bookmarks-organizer/issues/46 since Aug 7

The broken search sometimes does work sometimes won't finish , from what i understand there is a needed api that is not yet available (atleast on the stable ffx release)

This extension has potential when the 57 hits , looking foward to test it (no new update rip rating)

What's the point of finding duplicates if you can't go through the list and choose which ones to delete?

I've got 8200+ bookmarks and the "broken" bookmark detector has been running for over 10 minutes with absolutely no progress indication.

There are other, more feature-rich bookmark managers out there...uninstalling this add-on.

I had written a review that perhaps wasn't fair and I apologize to the developer. I deleted the old one. This is a new review.

Regarding the scan locking up, I think if you have a lot of duplicate bookmarks, what you need to do is start by dealing with those before you have it look for dead links. Once I did that, it went much more quickly when looking for the dead links and it did complete the scan. This extension also worked to fix redirects and stuff. You have to look over each one because it did find some false positives, which is natural and I think it even said to be careful in the dialogue itself. Can't remember for sure, but just don't blindly click your way through this stuff.

I don't know how I had so many duplicates, but it would have been nice to have had a way to select them in bulk.

Endlich mal eine SW die tut was sie verspricht. Einfach und gut; was kann ich mehr sagen!
Moechte das Addon auch als .xpi file downloaden, aber wie???
Gerne einen Hinweis.
Gruesse

After installing the add-on, I restarted FF 52.3.0 (running Mac OS X 10.11.6). Then I chose "broken bookmarks" and the add-on found 140.063 (yes 140 thousands!) bookmarks. Then I clicked on "check bookmark" and after 5 minutes I saw 211 checked but after 20 minutes the number of items checked was still 211. No numbers in warmings and errors fields. The add on is still working because I see in the middle of the window 3 circles moving ... and I cannot have any feedback nor choose any other option (like "duplicates", for instance). I'm (sadly) going to remove the add on ...unless I can have any suggestion to have the add on working ... I can't ever rate this add on...maybe too much bookmarks?

Hm. Also grundsätzlich scheint das Add-On seinen Job zu erledigen, bleibt aber auch bei mir bei der Überprüfung des letzten Lesezeichens hängen. Keine Ahnung, warum. Aber immerhin musste das Tool auch 6357 Bookmarks prüfen und hat 2989 Warnungen bzw. 1061 Fehler festgestellt. Bringt natürlich nichts, wenn das Ergebnis nicht validiert werden kann. Von daher nur drei Sterne.
Ich hoffe aber, das es noch etwas wird mit dem Add-On, da ich meine Bookmarks wirklich gerne mal bereinigen würde - was aber bisher mit keinem Tool gelang.

Edit: Ich habe es heute (28. 08. 2017) nochmals probiert und diesmal funktionierte sowohl der Suchvorgang sowie die anschliessende Validierung einwandfrei. Ich weiss nicht, warum es gestern nicht geklappt hat, aber vielleicht lag es an einem vom Author bereits in einem Kommentar erwähnten Timeout.
Also falls es bei euch nicht auf Anhieb funktioniert, vielleicht einfach noch einmal zu einem anderen Zeitpunkt probieren...
Sterne habe ich auf fünf erhöht, denn auch wenn da noch irgendwo ein (kleiner) Bug sein sollte, konnte ich zumindest das erste Mal überhaupt meine Bookmarks bereinigen.

- Restarted FF after installing.
- Opened the Firefox extension.
- Selected Broken Bookmarks.
- Selected Check Bookmarks...
- It scanned 4979 bookmarks.
- It identified 1453 warnings.
- It also identified 381 errors.

THEN NOTHING - (waited for 12 minutes)
The 'dot' progress indicator kept moving.


Selected Duplicates > Check Bookmarks.
Nothing !

Selected Missing Bookmark Names > Check Bookmarks.
Nothing !

Sehr gut und logisch aufgebaut, schlicht und übersichtlich im Design, funktioniert einwandfrei.
Der derzeit beste Bookmark-Checker.

Hallo,

ein tolles Addon (Bookmarks Organizer 1.3.0), wenn es denn den Suchvorgang vollständig beenden würde.
Und nutze Win 7 Pro 64 bit, Firefox 54.01 64 bit. Für die Durchführung habe ich alle Add Ons deaktiviert.

Insgesamt habe ich 1064 Lesezeichen auf defekte Lesezeichen überprüft.
Nachdem recht schnell 1063 Lesezeichen geprüft wurden, war das Zwischenergebnis
Anzahl der Lesezeichen = 1064
Überprüft = 1063
Warnungen = 433
Fehler = 147
Nach dem letzten Zeichen wird nach über 30 Minuten immer noch gesucht.

Könnte es sein, das da noch ein kleiner Bug vorhanden ist? Oder bin ich nur zu ungeduldig und sollte lieber mehrere Stunden Wartezeit einplanen?

Die Prüfung nach doppelten Lesezeichen funktionierte übrigens einwandfrei und die gefundene Lesezeichen wurden auch aufgelistet und ließen sich größenteils auch löschen.

Scan
From 5125 checked 5123 and after an hour I closed that link